Which 357 revolver is next?

[petepeterson]

How about a 60-10 or 60-15? It's like a "mini" 686, and gets you close to snubby land, while retaining adjustable sights and shootability.

 

[Daimler1989]

for shooting fun on the range, since you are not allowed to carry (like me in Germany) I can recommend this one (not as a .44 Special = 696, but as a .357 Magnum = 686 3")



or this one



regards
Ulrich

 

[jackmoineau]

The 686 is about as good as it gets for a .357 magnum revolver. Instead of another .357 Mag, get a K frame .22lr revolver - a 17/18/617 model or the pre-model number equivalent. They are great shooters.
If it has to be a .357 mag, consider a Colt Python or maybe a Kimber or Ruger (SA or DA) so you can experience a different brand. If it has to be a S&W, get an N frame (27 or 28). A colt SAA is probably out of your price range.
And don't forget to look for a Marlin 1894 in .357 Magnum. A great rifle companion to any .357 Magnum revolver.

The authorization paper I have is only for a 38/357 revolver, not a 22...I would have to pay for another authorization request, but indeed, a 22 LR revolver is a joy to shoot (I once tried the 617 of a friend). Thx for the tip for the Marlin, might consider it when I'll have my license for "long guns"! My 357 ammo could therefore be used with 2 guns

I know you mentioned 357 but consider a model 10 snubnose or pre model 10 hand snubnose. I’m a big fan of snubbies and have both which I really Er n joy shooting. I’d also consider a new Colt Cobra 38 2”. I own one and think they’re a better value than an older model 10 or pre 10. The model 10 I own was probably a night stand gun and hardly ever shot. I don’t remember off hand what dash number it is but seem to remember it was made in 1964. Might be wrong but it’s an older one. I bought it a few years ago and paid a premium to a friend but I’m happy I bought it.
I lucked out on my pre model 10 M&P. I bought it from a friend who was friends with the original owner, a police officer in Chicago. It was purchased new in 1948, my birth year, and used as a backup until he sold it to my friend in 1960. It sat in his safe and I bought it about 4 years ago. It too is in very nice condition.
In my area of the Eastern US the new Colt Cobra base model is about the same price as a very clean model 10 2” with no papers or box. The heavier frame guns like the model 10 and new stainless Cobra make for enjoyable shooting. I’m biased, I think I have 14 snubbies now.
Thinking about it, here are two more options. First is a new Colt 3” King Cobra 357 and second a vintage Smith 66-2 2.5” 357. You can’t go wrong with either.

Model 10 is beautiful, but retails for about * 2000 / $ 2300 here...I never shot a Colt, but think I prefer the way smith cylinders open.

Korth Mongoose…

If I had the money, I'd rather go with a Manurhin MR73!

Does your paperwork specify that you buy a 357 revolver, or can it be any hand gun?
I like 9mm for target shooting. Ammo is relatively inexpensive. I recently purchased a Canik SFx Rival S that is tough to beat for the money (I paid $800 usd).
If you want a revolver, a model 27, 28, or 19 would be good in a 4 or 6 inch barrel.

I have one more paper for a revolver and another one for a pistol in 9 mm, so that's the other part of the research (after Glock 17...).

for shooting fun on the range, since you are not allowed to carry (like me in Germany) I can recommend this one (not as a .44 Special = 696, but as a .357 Magnum = 686 3")
or this one
regards
Ulrich

Which models are these?

When I was in the shop, they had these for sale. I was more focused on the purchase of my 686, so didn't bother to ask the exact references, but might be interesting.

Seems like a 66 or 19 might be a good option. Anyway, if the magic doesn't speak when I take it in hand, I'll not buy it.

 

[jackmoineau]

Have you considered a 7 shot 9mm 986?

Beautiful, but I can't buy it with my authorization paper which specifies the caliber of the revolver (38/357).

 

[Beju]

If I had the money, I'd rather go with a Manurhin MR73!

If it makes you feel better, if you're in to shooting double action rapidly, the MR73 is a worse choice than the S&Ws in spite of the cost. The cylinder stop spring design just isn't very good.

 

[Baxter6551]

Jackmoineau the models are:
Top left model 19 2.5 inch with uncle mikes (Craig Spegel design) rubber grips
Top right model 19 with original stocks
Bottom left model 66 2.5 inch
Bottom right model 686 2.5 inch.

 

[jackmoineau]

Jackmoineau the models are:
Top left model 19 2.5 inch with uncle mikes (Craig Spegel design) rubber grips
Top right model 19 with original stocks
Bottom left model 66 2.5 inch
Bottom right model 686 2.5 inch.

Thanks a lot for the info! I'll try to go back to the shop to check them, I found a few YouTube videos reviewing how to inspect a used revolvers.

[ame]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZgsWqHuytN8[/ame]

[ame]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qst0W4YfikY[/ame]

 

[SLT223]

Why not be the first person in Belgium to have a 686 Mountain Gun?

 

[Shoebox1.1]

This is easy. New model 27. Sooo much fun eats 357 magnums like candy

 

[Bobbysixkiller]

Look for a model 27 or 28. Can’t go wrong with a big N frame for range duty. Blows me away that a model 10 is $2000. They are the most common revolver in the world. Over 6 million made. I guess it comes down to what you find that is available. Your 686 is probably one of if not the finest 357 revolver ever produced. Such solid guns.

 

[BoulderTroll]

I'll be the odd man out and suggest something different. Since you already have a 686, have you considered a Single Action Army? It's not like the gun needs to fill a tactical or defense roll, and I have to say, my Uberti SAA clones are the most fun handgun I've ever shot. They make even 357 magnum rounds feel very smooth and tame. Plus, they are insanely well-made for the money, they would provide a very different shooting experience from your 686, and they ooze cool factor. To top it off, they come in so many different barrel lengths and styles to choose from:

 

[jeffrefrig]

I’m another choice for the M27. Mine is a 27-9 I bought new. I sent it back in for a couple issues. It’s a nice shooter, but I can’t compare because I don’t have a 686 nor have I ever shot one.
Another gun that, IMO, would be the SA/DA Ruger revolver. You can’t beat the price new compared to our forum’s namesake and Black Beauty’s guns.
But if you haven’t yet check the M27 S&W and the Ruger revolvers out.
Good luck! I like spending other people’s money!

 

[Maximus Rex]

Greetings to our friends in Belgium. This is just my $.02 but I’ve found that revolvers are like girlfriends, some you like and some you don’t and some like you and others don’t! Honestly, the feel and balance of the M27 is unmatched by any other revolver IMHO especially one with a 6 inch barrel. I suspect in the final analysis you will enjoy any particular S&W chambered in 357 magnum you’re able to purchase. Good luck and enjoy your toys!

 

[erikpolcrack]

I would consider the S&W Model 28 or the Sturm Ruger GP-100.

 

[Paul01223]

Why not a 327 TRR8. 8 shot 357mag with a light weight scandium alloy frame.

 

[sniper]

It's lighter, but the S&W Model 60 3" is also a viable choice.

 

[chief38]

Look at a Colt Python - you'll buy a Colt Python. Their new line up of Python's is even better than the original - and you can see yourself in their new blued guns too. Gorgeous!

 

[Hawg Rider]

Welkom, jackmoineau. From what I've seen from some other Forum members, there are quite a few nice vintage S&W revolvers available in Europe. That may not be the case in Belgium, so you may have to go searching. Since your paperwork dictates a .357 Magnum revolver, you have lots of models to choose from if they're available. If you like vintage revolvers (nickel or blued finish), there are Model 19, 27, 28, and 586. Their stainless steel cousins (Models 66, 627, 686, etc.) are also very nice revolvers. If you want a brand new revolver, S&W is making very nice Model 19, 27, 340, 640, 60, 586, 686, and even a Heavy Duty N-frame. There are also the Performance Center models. Most of my modest collection is comprised of vintage revolvers, but I do have some newer .357 Magnums (627-5, 686-6 Plus), too. Veel geluk voor jou!

 

[gwpercle]

Ruger Blackhawk - 357 Magnum
Old School SA can be a lot of shooting fun .
Gary

 

[Mike LaNier]

Sadly, here in the Soviet Socialist Republic of Oregon, our Legislature is pushing for the same kind of regulations you are dealing with; a 'permit-to-purchase' from the State before you can even make an offer on a gun, and the requirements for the 'permit' are about the same as getting a concealed carry permit, including background check by the FBI, etc., and a fee, of course! Then, when you buy the gun, you must go through the Federal background check process. Simply amazing....

Having said all that, I interpreted your question was limited to the .357 caliber, which is one of the best all-around cartridges extant. I might be so bold as to suggest a K-frame Smith & Wesson with a short (snubbie) barrel; a Model 19 or perhaps one of the new L-frame guns would suffice. I have one, and it is a favorite handgun due to size and how it shoots. Just a thought!