Which one should I sell/keep?

[heeter3]

JW5400,if it was me I would keep both of them.Ive let to many get away that I regret on a daily basis.Mine will go away when I'm gone and hopefully my son or grandsons decide to keep them.

 

[44wheelman]

Id keep the later one as well, condition is everything.

 

[rpv-ak]

Looking for some opinions. I know many people will disagree with me but I think I have more model 60's than I need so I agreed to sell one to a friend.
My question, which one should I keep or sell? Both are shooters without matching stocks. Both great guns!
One is a no dash from about 1976, obviously pinned barrel, etc. highly polished, and the other is a 60-3, both excellent condition.
Can't decide if I want to keep the older pinned barrel or the -3 with the upgrades.
I would appreciate your thoughts.

Thanks, John
View attachment 754242

Unless you simply a collector, the pinned barrel shouldn't be a consideration to sell or keep. Besides, if you or a previous owner polished it, that's a hit on collectability and value. No serious collector would touch it. They're both machined with left hand threading. Which is the better revolver? Which one actually "speaks" to you?

 

[Ccwlaw]

Which one has the screws out of proper order and how can you tell?