Which one ?

[old pipefitter]

Came out of retirement for gun money so I'm thinking I need another snubby .357. I have a 340 so J frame is covered. Have a 3 1/2 inch pre 27 and a TRR8. So which would I get more use out of a 627 PC 2 1/2 OR a 686 PC snub. Not for carry as there too big for an old guy with no hips or butt.

 

[Valmet]

If you’re coming out of retirement to raise gun money, buy both.

 

[Lou_the_welder]

I vote the 627 shorty! 8 times the fun!! What's not to like?

 

[Groo01]

Came out of retirement for gun money so I'm thinking I need another snubby .357. I have a 340 so J frame is covered. Have a 3 1/2 inch pre 27 and a TRR8. So which would I get more use out of a 627 PC 2 1/2 OR a 686 PC snub. Not for carry as there too big for an old guy with no hips or butt.

Groo here
Neither ,, A new 2 3/4 in M66 combat magnum or a 3in M19 PC carry comp.

 

[kennethg]

I would have to go with a 2 1/2" model 19 or 66 if I could find one. These are just great revolvers.

 

[old pipefitter]

Yes a 2 1/2 inch 19 is kind of on my radar. that would be a much more classic gun. I kind of have a hard time keeping stainless guns except for a Marlin 1894. Stainless guns don't have a soul like a blued and Walnut gun