Final Results:
Best Modified / Customized S&W:
S&WCA member volunteer, (anyone jump in please) review votes to make sure correct. Confusing to determine with all the banter.
6 votes for #9 SixgunStrumpet, 1st model 44 DA cut barrel, bobbed hammer, carry.
(5 votes #69 Keith44SPL Three Fifty Seven / Forty Four Spl. / First year Registered Magnum)
First Prize: Choice of the S&WCA embroidered "whatchamacallit" or a "helpful hints" brochure.
......................................................................................
>>>> Best Rube Goldber-esque that started life as a S&W: goes to: Steelslayers post #38
described as: 1937 Brazilian, milled for adjustable sights, 357 cylinder reamed to 45 colt and cut for moon clips to fire 45 acp. grip frame reworked so I could fasten stock and get shape I wanted. 16 1/2" barrel installed. 2 lugs to hold fore stock and it has a front lug for ejector rod. Still needs a trip through the blue tank.
PRIZE: whichever of the 2 main prizes the winner of "Best Modified" does not want.
........................................................................................
and honorable mention for Best Accessory: post #57, SixgunStrumpet's unique, elaborate Roper stocks.
Votes for Best Modified / Customized S&W
Votes for Best Rube Goldberg-esque S&W
Votes for best accessory
ONE VOTE by NUMBER of Post in this thread. If more than one gun posted in that post, describe the winning gun.
>>>>>> Vote starting, May 1, 2018, Voting ends at Midnight 5/1/2018
We all had fun with Dave's ( Thinnes ) contest for the "prettiest" S&W back on 2/26/2018, I thought that we'd go on for another round.
This time, the best MODIFIED / CUSTOMIZED S&W revolver, starting now, ending April 30, 2018.
The most innovative, functional, professional gunsmith or hobbyist MODIFIED / CUSTOMIZED from standard model configuration to the most grotesque, Rube Goldberg-esque, entries are permitted.
UPDATED / AMENDED 4/18/18 (after seeing the Brazilian Rifle conversion. It's going to be tough to beat this one for the Rube award) :
There will be 1 winner for the best, no-nonsense, modified S&W Revolver
... and ...
1 consolation / booby prize (to be determined later) for the best Rube Goldberg-esque S&W.
I will ask members for votes on the best Rube Goldberg-esque S&W. A "Rube" entry can include FrankenGun S&Ws like this one:
Never Yet Melted >> Rube Goldberg's 48-Shot Revolver
but NOT "this" specific gun. You still must currently own or have previously owned it. NO CHEATING in this category, please.
And I will ask the membership to also judge on the best, no-nonsense, modified S&W. (This way I keep the few friends I have)
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HOLD ALL VOTES UNTIL May 1, 2018 <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
PRIZE: S&W Helpful Hints brochure (original) Post Paid to the upper 48 United States. Alternate Prize to S&WCA members only: a woven blue S&WCA (emblem attached) belt-hanging pen and goodie holder that I have NO clue as to who made it, where it came from or what the heck the proper definition of this item is.
Rules: Must be a Smith & Wesson revolver you currently own or have owned in the past. At very least, it must have started life as a production model Smith & Wesson.
Modified / Customized could be as simple as a pair of stocks or custom finish to more elaborate reconstructive or enhancement type modifications. including engraving.
Value or rarity of your entry is not a consideration. An old S&W with a value of $200 S&W has the same chance as another worth $20,000, but please, serious entries only.
I reserve the option to ask for votes or to elect a member or members as assistant judge(s) ... or not.
I, being the impartial and sole judge, will not enter to win this worthless, errr, I mean "priceless" S&WCA novelty or a Helpful Hints brochure, that does have value. Good luck !!!
Best Modified / Customized S&W:
S&WCA member volunteer, (anyone jump in please) review votes to make sure correct. Confusing to determine with all the banter.
6 votes for #9 SixgunStrumpet, 1st model 44 DA cut barrel, bobbed hammer, carry.
(5 votes #69 Keith44SPL Three Fifty Seven / Forty Four Spl. / First year Registered Magnum)
First Prize: Choice of the S&WCA embroidered "whatchamacallit" or a "helpful hints" brochure.
......................................................................................
>>>> Best Rube Goldber-esque that started life as a S&W: goes to: Steelslayers post #38
described as: 1937 Brazilian, milled for adjustable sights, 357 cylinder reamed to 45 colt and cut for moon clips to fire 45 acp. grip frame reworked so I could fasten stock and get shape I wanted. 16 1/2" barrel installed. 2 lugs to hold fore stock and it has a front lug for ejector rod. Still needs a trip through the blue tank.
PRIZE: whichever of the 2 main prizes the winner of "Best Modified" does not want.
........................................................................................
and honorable mention for Best Accessory: post #57, SixgunStrumpet's unique, elaborate Roper stocks.
Votes for Best Modified / Customized S&W
Votes for Best Rube Goldberg-esque S&W
Votes for best accessory
ONE VOTE by NUMBER of Post in this thread. If more than one gun posted in that post, describe the winning gun.
>>>>>> Vote starting, May 1, 2018, Voting ends at Midnight 5/1/2018
We all had fun with Dave's ( Thinnes ) contest for the "prettiest" S&W back on 2/26/2018, I thought that we'd go on for another round.
This time, the best MODIFIED / CUSTOMIZED S&W revolver, starting now, ending April 30, 2018.
The most innovative, functional, professional gunsmith or hobbyist MODIFIED / CUSTOMIZED from standard model configuration to the most grotesque, Rube Goldberg-esque, entries are permitted.
UPDATED / AMENDED 4/18/18 (after seeing the Brazilian Rifle conversion. It's going to be tough to beat this one for the Rube award) :
There will be 1 winner for the best, no-nonsense, modified S&W Revolver
... and ...
1 consolation / booby prize (to be determined later) for the best Rube Goldberg-esque S&W.
I will ask members for votes on the best Rube Goldberg-esque S&W. A "Rube" entry can include FrankenGun S&Ws like this one:
Never Yet Melted >> Rube Goldberg's 48-Shot Revolver
but NOT "this" specific gun. You still must currently own or have previously owned it. NO CHEATING in this category, please.

And I will ask the membership to also judge on the best, no-nonsense, modified S&W. (This way I keep the few friends I have)

>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HOLD ALL VOTES UNTIL May 1, 2018 <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
PRIZE: S&W Helpful Hints brochure (original) Post Paid to the upper 48 United States. Alternate Prize to S&WCA members only: a woven blue S&WCA (emblem attached) belt-hanging pen and goodie holder that I have NO clue as to who made it, where it came from or what the heck the proper definition of this item is.
Rules: Must be a Smith & Wesson revolver you currently own or have owned in the past. At very least, it must have started life as a production model Smith & Wesson.
Modified / Customized could be as simple as a pair of stocks or custom finish to more elaborate reconstructive or enhancement type modifications. including engraving.
Value or rarity of your entry is not a consideration. An old S&W with a value of $200 S&W has the same chance as another worth $20,000, but please, serious entries only.
I reserve the option to ask for votes or to elect a member or members as assistant judge(s) ... or not.
I, being the impartial and sole judge, will not enter to win this worthless, errr, I mean "priceless" S&WCA novelty or a Helpful Hints brochure, that does have value. Good luck !!!

Attachments
Last edited: