Ed,
I'm certainly no expert on percussion caps, but I have a few old tins and these photos may provide some insight.
First up is tin of United States Army Caps manufactured by the Union Metallic Cartridge Company. It's my understanding that these are Civil War era caps. You can see the priming compound inside.
The next two tins were manufactured by Winchester and are "foil lined". The Hick's caps date to the 1880's and are simply marked "Winchester Repeating Arms Company". The Goldmark's caps are obviously later, since they're labeled "Division of Olin Industries Inc." Both are sealed and I'm not opening them.
This last tin has long since lost its label, so I don't know who manufactured it. It's about the same diameter as the Winchester tins, but it's about 50% deeper. These caps are also foil lined. The single cap next to the foil disc (bottom photo) still has the foil in place. The two caps above them are missing the foil, which allows you to see the yellow priming compound. I looked at the compound under a loupe and it slightly extends up the inside of the caps and was almost certainly applied as a liquid solution. No sign of paper here.
The last photo shows Italian ring caps for toy/theatrical guns and dates from the 1990's. You can see the compound in the plastic caps and the package lists the ingredients.