The best all around do everything pistol!

SOS24 said:
I think the answer for specific gun is a personal preference, but for me there are some specific characteristics:
- concealable size - this varies by person, but for me it is compact or smaller
- reliable and accurate
- capacity of 10+ rounds, with the more the better. If it holds more than 10rds, 10rd magazines must be available in case travel to a state with mag limits
- rail, just in case want to mount light or laser
- not requirement but ability to convert calibers by changing changing barrel and mags, is a benefit

For me a P229r in .40 would be the best with 9mm and .22 conversion barrel and magazines fits all my requirements.
Click to expand...

I would have to agree on the Sig Sauer. I like the autos with conversion barrels. I do like the .40 to .357 barrel swap. Only thing is I dont see to many 9mm conversions.
 
The 9mm Luger is the greatest cartridge in the known world at this time. So consider that in your thoughts.
 
Just my choice, I would go with a CZ 75 in 9mm. I have a late pre B, about the only issue I face is that the magwell isn't quite as open as the later ones, so it doesn't take new 16 rd mags (it does take the 18 rd SP 01 mags).

All steel construction, including the frame. Parkerized, with a polycoat finish. If the paint gets scuffed, the park under it still protects the gun. Get through the park, you can still throw oil on it and it stays blue. I feel steel is more resilient than plastic or aluminum. In a scuffle, I want steel to smack someone, and a great grip to maintain control of the weapon.

"Heavy", but that weight is deceptive. It is a sleek gun, a lot easier to hide inside the waistband than you'd suspect, less bulky than a Sig or Beretta. A lot of "melted" curves, not much in sharp edges to snag. Points like a dream, soaks up recoil nicely. Feels fantastic in the grip. Very balanced. Longer sight radius seems to give me better accuracy at range.

Carry cocked and locked, or easily lower the hammer on your thumb, your call.

32826179886_6dd5d55405_c.jpg
 
I think we can all agree that there is no one answer to this question, but it is a fun thought exercise, so kudos to dandyrandy for posing it. I think EVERYBODY loves the Smith and Wesson Model 19 (wish I still had one!), and nobody would feel under-armed with one. If it was a TEOTWAWKI situation, I'd be happy with my Glock 17L. Six-inch barrel, eight-inch sight radius, 24 ounces, 9 1/2 inch overall length, 17-shot and a nice boost in 9mm Parabellum velocity while decreasing noise and recoil. All this in a package about the size of a four-inch barreled Police Positive, without the cylinder bulge. Points like a revolver, too. But, boy, those Combat Magnums.....
 
When I was in my 20's, I took a 1911 45 everywhere I could. Camp, Back packing and canoeing! I also carried a 60 pound backpack (and liked it). Now I'm 61, If I go anywhere that requires a backpack, I think 35 pounds is too much. On those few overnight treks, I carry an old Colt Cobra or Agent and 6 spare shots. But for an afternoon in the woods, I still love a 1911 or a 1917.

Ivan
 
Now that I have partially stopped drooling over these pics I will try to post. I was sitting here thinking about my answer but couldn't choose just one. I tend to carry a SP101 most of the time, .357 mag, you can load it hot for protection or light for range. Then the 1911s came to mind, if someone said you can no longer have one of them I would offer my arm instead! Oh yeah, the 3rd gen Smiths...never had one fail me yet. Now I have to go check my limited stash money..
 
How about one of each? My Kimber Ultra Carry Series I has been as flawless a performer as one could hope; purchased in 2000 when Kimber quality was still top notch.

And then there's my Model 66-4.....

Choices, choices......
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1946.jpg
    IMG_1946.jpg
    181.3 KB · Views: 48
  • IMG_1716.JPG
    IMG_1716.JPG
    155.7 KB · Views: 49
  • IMG_1293.JPG
    IMG_1293.JPG
    152.5 KB · Views: 64
  • IMG_1146.jpg
    IMG_1146.jpg
    115.5 KB · Views: 67
Last edited:
Based on your parameters and my own personal needs, I'd have to go with a Glock 19, even though I prefer revolvers. Not too expensive, easily replaceable, parts are readily available, 9mm ammo is inexpensive and available most places, mags are inexpensive, good reputation for reliability, and it's compact enough to conceal but big enough to be easy to shoot.

If I were to stay with the revolver, I would pick a 3" S&W 65 as a good all-around gun. The only issue I have with choosing it is gun and spare parts availability.
 
dandyrandy said:
Im surprised no one has mentioned the Ruger SP101 yet.
Click to expand...

I think that would be a really good choice. While I think a 3" S&W 65 would be a better choice, the SP101 would probably be close behind. I've often thought a DAO Wiley Clapp SP101 with a bobbed hammer would suit me quite well.
 
Since you mentioned the Gestapo and gun confiscation I pick my G19 for the following reasons.
It's 9mm and for ammo resupply purposes, the most readily available caliber anywhere in the world. It's very concealable. It holds 15 rds. Lastly it goes bang every time the trigger is pulled. Super simple and the most reliable pistol I own.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

KSDrifter
M&P40 Shield M2.0 Series 357 Build
Replies
2
Views
67
KSDrifter
KSDrifter
R
22 short vs air rifle
2 3
Replies
53
Views
3K
CAJUNLAWYER
CAJUNLAWYER
Shotguncoach
HomeSmith TrainWreck: Summer of 67
2
Replies
26
Views
1K
Marksman
M
J
10mm M&P PC with Apex Trigger Reset Failure
Replies
9
Views
394
hardluk1
H
Y
SW .38 Chiefs Special Stainless Steel Revolver Mod 60
Replies
9
Views
926
ajgunner
ajgunner

Latest posts

Back
Top