RoninPhx
Member
another comment
Now my time was packing a model 19 in the 70's on a sheriff's department.
We routinely trained with what at the time, politically incorrect, was called a mexican quail shoot. you stood in a circle, and at the whistle turned and fired.
You had six six inch diameter targets, numbered one to six in varied order and distance. You had to start with one and go to six. Had to keep firing if you missed one at the same target. You had to do this with a tactical reload in less than 15 seconds. My average time was somewhere around 8 to 9 seconds hitting all six targets twice.
I have a friend that from a holstered postion can hit six targets at about seven yards in about 1.30 seconds. He also took rob leatham one time in competition too.
You might not believe it until you see it done.
I like high cap mags, but don't anyone ever tell you are undergunned with a revolver if you are proficient enough.
the 125 grain jcp was a late bloomer to magnum pistols, and they the pistols that is were designed around that 158grain bullet.
While in recent years my toys have been more in the .41magnum and up range, to this day i don't think there is anything around that i would be uncomfortable facing with a model 19 with only six rounds. And a couple of speed loaders.
I might add at the time in the 70's, the instructors i had preached proficiency, skill, with a handgun rather than spray and pray. A lot of it has to do with mindset by the way
I was going to add i would probably use the 158grain, which you have already chosen. A lot of this for penetration reasons on car bodies, glass, barricade, etc.I went to the range and tried 25 rounds of both. The 158gr seemed to group better for me from point shoulder shooting and from supported positions. I'm going to go with the 158gr. Thanks for all your opinions. I know some feel it's a foolish idea to carry a revolver in this day and age, but I shoot it so much better than our glocks. We also had a bad problem with our model 22 and a failure to feed. I also feel that with all the 1911 and Sig p220's around with 8-10 rounds magazines that I'm not that out gunned. I can reload with my moon clips as fast as most with a semi-auto. I also like the stopping power and reputation of the 357 along with the reliability of a revolver. Once again thank you all for your thoughts and opinions on this. I feel that your opinions are better than most published "experts".
Now my time was packing a model 19 in the 70's on a sheriff's department.
We routinely trained with what at the time, politically incorrect, was called a mexican quail shoot. you stood in a circle, and at the whistle turned and fired.
You had six six inch diameter targets, numbered one to six in varied order and distance. You had to start with one and go to six. Had to keep firing if you missed one at the same target. You had to do this with a tactical reload in less than 15 seconds. My average time was somewhere around 8 to 9 seconds hitting all six targets twice.
I have a friend that from a holstered postion can hit six targets at about seven yards in about 1.30 seconds. He also took rob leatham one time in competition too.
You might not believe it until you see it done.
I like high cap mags, but don't anyone ever tell you are undergunned with a revolver if you are proficient enough.
the 125 grain jcp was a late bloomer to magnum pistols, and they the pistols that is were designed around that 158grain bullet.
While in recent years my toys have been more in the .41magnum and up range, to this day i don't think there is anything around that i would be uncomfortable facing with a model 19 with only six rounds. And a couple of speed loaders.
I might add at the time in the 70's, the instructors i had preached proficiency, skill, with a handgun rather than spray and pray. A lot of it has to do with mindset by the way
Last edited: