Semi Automatic vs Revolver, what say you?

[diegobxr]

If you went to buy a handgun today, what would you buy and why? Y'all help a fella out. I'm trying not to be so "set in my ways" which is what wives say about their husbands after the age of 45. I'd buy another M&P revolver in a New York minute but, let's just say it would be "another one". I'm open for suggestions. WHAT SAY YOU?

Hi, sir.
I have a revolver and recently bought a semi-auto. I personally find the pistol a lot easier and faster to shoot, but it's just 'meh'. :/
On the other hand, I profoundly enjoy shooting revolvers. Handling them, loading them, even just looking at them.

I would buy revolvers 'til the cows come home and probably just keep a semi-auto, or two (ok, maybe three).

Regarding your purchase... If you are a revolver guy I suppose you'd prefer a steel framed, DA/SA pistol,or maybe even DAO.
Have you looked into some SIG SAUER's? I really like those.

Happy buying!

 

[crazyphil]

They are making a lot more Semi Autos now than revolvers. Over 6 to 1.
They are much more popular with younger folks. Probably because they
look cool in all the gunfights in movies and on tv.
About 40% of the Semi Autos being made are 9MM. Most popular caliber
I see on the range by far.
Get an instructor certification. Conduct classes for about 20 years.
Observe who shoots best and who has the least malfunctions. I did,
and I prefer revolvers.
I don't dis-like Semi Autos though. I shoot pretty good with my Colt
Gold Cup and my Model 22 .40 caliber Glock. Not too bad with my
Beretta M9 or my SIG P220 either.
But the main reason most folks have guns is for defense, and for that
I prefer revolvers. More reliable and simple operation, which is very
important when that stuff hits the fan.
Don't tell me I'm crazy. I know.

 

[sarg1c]

I have owned a number of semi-auto pistols...sold them all...replaced them with these...and it's only a portion of what I have all wheel guns...so, right tool for the right job!

I just went from auto to revolver last week. I like autos but traded my P95DC for a very nice Smith M10-5 whichLooks great.. I'm well pleased with the trade. A little big for carry,but just wanted it to shoot. Got a 637 and a Colt pocketlite to carry.

 

[BAM-BAM]

Old revolver guy myself....... didn't get my first auto until I was about 35 or so..........shooting revolvers at least 20 years by then.

Glocks have their place..... so do shovels..... I've had three...... Glocks that is... and numerous shovels...... a 19 and two 26s. Operative word is "had"...I still have the shovels!

As a revolver guy might I suggest "metal guns with wood grips"...............

A classic is the Smith Model 39 .........introduced in 1955 a 8+1, 9mm .... the 3913 is considered by many to be the best single stack concealed carry gun of the past 50 years ( wood grips are available from Hogue)

High Cap.......the timeless classic Browning/FN Hi-Power in production since 1935 ..... 13/15+1 single action....John Browning design.

S&Ws check out the Models 59, or the third generation 5906,6906 or 915.

IMO Beretta, Sig and CZ also make great guns........

 

[rwsmith]

Lots of good ideas here....

Did you say exactly what you wanted it for? Home defense, carry, general shooting?

You liked the Glock, so I presume you aren't adverse to having a 'plastic' gun. That would make me think you would like an S&W M&P of some sort.

Personally, I REALLY like third gen S&Ws but for carry, I have a couple of plastic autos and a Model 36, that is an 'old fashioned' all steel J frame revolver. My favorite of all is a 686 that I don't intend to carry, but it's great fun to shoot and does home duty quite well.

Keep us posted on which way you go.

 

[BIGDOC]

REVOLVER. As someone already stated....if I need more than six rounds....I'm the wrong place.

 

[joe44va]

It seems the defense lawyers prefer double action only guns, either revolver or semi-auto. I find I shoot revolvers better in single action and semi-autos better in double action. Rent some and try comparing rapid fire group size. If you're like most of us, one or two will stand out from the pack. 7 to 10 yards is good to show the differences.

 

[CustomChevyGuy]

To the OP, I'm not sure what your finances allow, but if you know you shoot the Glock well, then start there, by getting one you like. From there you can research and figure out which S&W you'll begin you collection with. Best of both worlds approach!

...semi-automatic?...what in tarnation is that?...

I think it's truck that shift's gears by itself

Let me help muddy the waters. Revolvers outnumber semi-autos in my collection. In semi-auto pistols, I have a S&W Model 439, then a Colt Government Model, a Springfield Armory Trophy Match, a Ruger Commander, and a Mauser HSC.

I started my pistol experience with the Government Model, thinking I could shoot bullseye with it. The Trophy Match became my 45 bullseye gun. I bought the 439 for shooting steel plates. I bought the Commander and the HSC once I entered the world of concealed carry.

Honestly, I am not fond of plastic or polymer guns, nor do I like striker fired handguns. My handguns have to be graced with steel and walnut, and must be equipped with a firing pin. We all have our unique taste and preferences in firearms, so it is hard to suggest one firearm over another. That said, I would suggest a quality 1911 or a second generation S&W semi-auto.

How often do you carry the Commander 1911? What style of holster do you use? Is yours solid steel frame and slide, or do you have a lighter frame?
I've been considering adding a 1911 for carry rotation, and because I've got bit by that bug..

 

[Whitwabit]

Auto .. I can carry 17+1 ..revolver would have to be reloaded 2 times .. and I carry another 17 rounds on my off side .. you can't match that with any revolver ..

Don't think the BG is going to wait for you to reload after you shoot 6 rounds off .. he could have a 30 round magazine in that stolen Glock he has .. seems they are the magazine sought after by the bangers ..

 

[DevilDog72]

The one you can operate while still half asleep when the perp comes into your home in the dead of night... the one you can use effectively when you are confronted by a surprise altercation not of your choosing at a time you are not fully prepared for....... what ever it is it must work every time in all weather without even thinking about it. I have both and can accomplish all the above, that said, I carry a Mdl 19 or 66 snub.. it/they are also my night stand gun. Your choice.

 

[Big Cholla]

Non of us Posters can give you valid advice on specific handguns. That is something you have to figure out for yourself. Your hand size, grip strength, finger length, in short the ergonomics of griping and operating a handgun is specific to YOU. I will say this: Anyone that wants to "be prepared" should have a semi-auto in 22 LR, 9 mm and 45 acp. Those three calibers dominate the field and the ammo will be available longer and cheaper than any of the others. One should be circumspect in picking out those three handguns knowing that you and your loved ones lives could be protected by their use. Get competent with your semis and stay competent with your revolvers. Put lots of ammo for all your calibers in secure storage. ............

 

[cb56]

Go with whatever you feel most comfortable with.
Me? This is my meager armory so far....

 

[carpriver]

There is no right or wrong choice, I own mostly S&W revolvers, which I have carried and still do on occasion, I own one fantastic plastic hand gun, which was a present from my wife a XD9. my go to everyday gun is my stable of 1911's, a MIL SPEC, A Loaded, 9 mm Range Officer, A Ranger Officer compact in 45 ACP, an a Ruger Commander in 9mm. For the middle of the night bump I want a 12 ga loaded with buckshot, without my glasses I just want to point it rack a round and say leave now or be carried out.

What matters most is being able to hit what you aim at. A revolvers require you to hit you target in the vitals spots. I think having 18+1 encourages the spray and pray approach to shooting.

And with practice a revolver can be reloaded as fast as a semi auto.

All opinions stated here are in no way to be takes as fact.

 

[ImprovedModel56Fan]

REVOLVER. As someone already stated....if I need more than six rounds....I'm the wrong place.

If I need a gun, I'm in the wrong place. It could happen, and that's why I carry a gun.

 

[Arik]

REVOLVER. As someone already stated....if I need more than six rounds....I'm the wrong place.

How about 1 round?

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk