Chubbo
Member
Damascus Steel
I believe Mule Packer hit the proverbial "Nail on the Head", with his description of today's "Damascus Steel". Of course, the original true methods of producing "Damascus Steel", have been lost, over many centuries. Even the old fable, about tempering the steel, by plunging the red hot blade into the body of a slave, killing him, and thereby tempering the steel. I believe that today's "Damascus Steel" is intended, mainly for it's pleasing appearance, to some of us, Although It can be made for field use, why use it, when all of the modern, and superior steels are available? It all boils down to choosing what "Flops Your Mop". We can enjoy it, or just look in the other direction. "My two cents worth".
Chubbo
First off, remember, all Damascus steel isn't the same. Just because somebody calls it "Damascus," doesn't necessarily mean that it's high quality.
Here...let me quote from the "Ask a Knife Maker" site:
"First, let's do a little freshening up on what exactly "Damascus steel" is. Damascus, Wootz, and patternweld are all names given to different types of steels and blades. Basically, the idea is that two or more steel alloys are forged/cast together through various methods to give the wavy artistic pattern that comes from such a layering process. Unfortunately, the technique for making both Damascus and Wootz steel has been lost to the centuries. Anyone claiming to be making authentic Wootz/Damascus these days is delusional. Or lying..."
What we refer to as "Damascus steel" today is really "pattern-weld." In other words, a combination of anywhere from two to five different steels combined in a wavy pattern....not actually folded together as in true Damascus.
What constitutes quality is the types of steel used in the pattern-welding. If you use cheap steel, you get a cheap knife....but it looks pretty.
Bottom line...all Damascus steel is not the same.
I believe Mule Packer hit the proverbial "Nail on the Head", with his description of today's "Damascus Steel". Of course, the original true methods of producing "Damascus Steel", have been lost, over many centuries. Even the old fable, about tempering the steel, by plunging the red hot blade into the body of a slave, killing him, and thereby tempering the steel. I believe that today's "Damascus Steel" is intended, mainly for it's pleasing appearance, to some of us, Although It can be made for field use, why use it, when all of the modern, and superior steels are available? It all boils down to choosing what "Flops Your Mop". We can enjoy it, or just look in the other direction. "My two cents worth".
Chubbo