Very helpful guy at Leupold said that i was not using enough distance in my bore-sighting, at least 50 or better yet 100 yards is required. The scope/mount combo is fine for the AR.
I'm glad you called. Any scope worth having on an AR should be able to be zeroed at 50 yards. This equates to zeroing at ~225 yards as well. Still, a 100 yard zero might be more suitable to this scope and mount combination.
He also said that on some AR applications a 20MOA mount helps in this situation. Next weekend more work to be done.
You shouldn't need a 20MOA mount for this application. The function of a 20MOA mount is to angle the scope down to allow more adjustment of the elevation. This is only ever needed for long range shooting i.e. greater than 1,000 yards.
This particular scope has 56MOA of elevation adjustment. This means that there is 28MOA of adjustment up or down. 1MOA at 50 yards is 1/2" so, this means the POI can be moved up 14" from zero. If mounted with quality rings (which you have), no scope should be further off than that regardless of price.
Further, if the POI is off by more than just a few inches with the elevation set to the middle, something is wrong with your scope.
I apologize for using the term "cheap" when talking about your scope. It's not a cheap scope in terms of quality. It is a quality scope. However, Leupold makes scopes from $230 to over $6K. In that range, you bought the lower end. Make no mistake, it's still a good scope and should work properly.
It's my belief that this will boil down to one of two things:
- Broken scope
- Improperly mounted
It's hard to mount the scope improperly when talking about a 1913 rail system (picatinny rail that all ARs have). So, I suspect you're doing everything right. It just happens that some scopes get knocked out of whack or are defective from the factory.
One last question; do you see the reticle move when you adjust it?