M52 Magazine Question

Joined
Oct 22, 2014
Messages
7,302
Reaction score
10,516
Location
Monroe cnty. Ohio
I bought some used m52 mags in a lot. They are all in very nice shape 7 look like they never been in a gun. The were each stored
separately and heavy oiled. My question is, how many different series of 52 mags were made by S&W. I have 14 mags and they all have identical floor plate with S&W logo. 3 mags out of new batch have slightly smaller floor plate but still with S&W logo.
I’m aware 3k is selling aftermarkets, are these stamped with S&W.
I gobble up all the 52 and old model 41 mags I run across at a good price. From what I’m hearing on 3k mags I don’t want any.
Hoping I didn’t get slipped a Mickey.
 
Register to hide this ad
Yeah, a search for Model 52 turns them up.
I thought I might try one, but at $76 a pop, that is more than I am willing to risk on one of their products.

Don’t I remember a thread that ended with someone saying they don’t work?
 
Someone or maybe more than one said the 3k 52mags didn’t work, hard to remove, etc. I buy all the nice original 52 mags I come across for $100 or less. Recently got 2 off eBay by bid.
There were several on eBay to buy outright with NIB mags going as high as $299. Nobody buying at that but I see many going for
$150. That’s when I noticed some slickster slipping in 3k mags at $125. The original m41 mags are nuts too. I see them at $100 and even new mags for twice what you can buy them for anywhere. I have a dozen new 41 mags in packages. I will trade a new mag even up for a nice old model, but that’s far as it goes.
You would think the dies for S&W obsolete models would be on racks in a warehouse somewhere. You would think it would be cheaper to get hold of those dies than having new ones made. If
3k thinks there is money to be made, the volume must be there.
I might sell a few of mine and buy a new truck!
 
Realistically, how many magazines do you need for any one pistol?
Two, three, four or more? I have three mags for each pistol I use and rotate them for use. I don't anticipate needing more, but if I do I am sure I will find them. I sold a Swiss made P-210 when magazines for it started selling for over $125.00 a piece. I don't feed scalpers period. Triple K M52 mags are at a price I would pay if I needed them, but I don't. Even if they need some massaging at that price it isn't a bad deal. At least Triple K did something to help the shortage of M52 mags while all the other manufacturers sat on their hands including Smith and Wesson. They won't do anything to help us out, but they will come out with some overpriced "classic" firearm to help line their pockets. Why can't S&W re-make M52 magazines? Follow the money as in all other things.

Rick H.
 
Realistically, how many magazines do you need for any one pistol?
Two, three, four or more? I have three mags for each pistol I use and rotate them for use. I don't anticipate needing more, but if I do I am sure I will find them. I sold a Swiss made P-210 when magazines for it started selling for over $125.00 a piece. I don't feed scalpers period. Triple K M52 mags are at a price I would pay if I needed them, but I don't. Even if they need some massaging at that price it isn't a bad deal. At least Triple K did something to help the shortage of M52 mags while all the other manufacturers sat on their hands including Smith and Wesson. They won't do anything to help us out, but they will come out with some overpriced "classic" firearm to help line their pockets. Why can't S&W re-make M52 magazines? Follow the money as in all other things.

Rick H.

How many mags for each gun? Well it all depends. What is the gun being used for? Occasional range use - 3 or 4 sounds about right to me depending on how many rounds they hold and how much you abhor loading mags when you could be getting trigger time. Carry gun? I think 5 or 6. Three or four to practice with on a regular basis including dropping them on the ground during emergency reloads and then two that have been well range tested but are kept in better condition. I will keep one of the nicer ones in the gun and have one for reloads. Competition? Depends on the competition. Bullseye? Ideally I would have 13 magazines for each gun. 90 rounds fired 5 at a time. The slow fire portions allow plenty of time to reload mags. But the timed and rapid are ideally fired without the distraction of reloading 5 rounds between strings. 90 rounds minus 30 slow fire equals 60 rounds divided by 5 allowed to be loaded at a time equals 12 mags (plus one for a refire if necessary). Other gun disciplines would need their own ciphering depending on budget etc. So…it all depends.
 
Last edited:
Realistically, how many magazines do you need for any one pistol?
Two, three, four or more? I have three mags for each pistol I use and rotate them for use. I don't anticipate needing more, but if I do I am sure I will find them. I sold a Swiss made P-210 when magazines for it started selling for over $125.00 a piece. I don't feed scalpers period. Triple K M52 mags are at a price I would pay if I needed them, but I don't. Even if they need some massaging at that price it isn't a bad deal. At least Triple K did something to help the shortage of M52 mags while all the other manufacturers sat on their hands including Smith and Wesson. They won't do anything to help us out, but they will come out with some overpriced "classic" firearm to help line their pockets. Why can't S&W re-make M52 magazines? Follow the money as in all other things.

Rick H.
The older military men think of magazines as consumables or disposables. That's fine if you have a defense department keeping you supplied.

Here is how I do it.
-Three magazines stay loaded, and they get carried, one in the gun and two reloads on the belt.
-Two more are dedicated to the range and they get dropped, kicked, stepped on, lost on the ground somewheres. The Promags are OK for this. -Two more are kept for dry fire practice and are loaded with snap caps.
-One magazine is a "Barney mag". It is used to put one in the chamber, so I do not have to top off the carry mag. Named after Barney Fife.

Here are my beliefs and assumptions which inform these practices:
-Skills not gear. This is my most important belief. It is carried over in my mind from my experience as a musician.
-Administrative handling. If the magazine springs are prone to "take a set", then be aware that keeping carry mags loaded the way I do may become a problem. However, I have learned that with my guns it is repeated flexing that weakens and wears out the springs. After some years I needed to replace the spring on a Promag magazine. Another consideration is that I found when unloading and reloading the pistol that I kept rechambering the same round over and over pushing the projectile slightly deeper into the case each time.
-Shoot and move. I practice at the creek because our local range does not allow working from the holster. I believe in reloading on the move and sometimes I have dropped the spare while moving. I do not wish to go down on the ground looking for a dropped mag. Also, I believe in clearing malfunctions in exactly the same way every time, so it is better to just grab the other mag and keep going.

All comment and contradiction is welcome with my thanks.

Kind Regards RickH!
BrianD
 
Someone or maybe more than one said the 3k 52mags didn’t work, hard to remove, etc. I buy all the nice original 52 mags I come across for $100 or less. Recently got 2 off eBay by bid.
There were several on eBay to buy outright with NIB mags going as high as $299. Nobody buying at that but I see many going for
$150. That’s when I noticed some slickster slipping in 3k mags at $125. The original m41 mags are nuts too. I see them at $100 and even new mags for twice what you can buy them for anywhere. I have a dozen new 41 mags in packages. I will trade a new mag even up for a nice old model, but that’s far as it goes.
You would think the dies for S&W obsolete models would be on racks in a warehouse somewhere. You would think it would be cheaper to get hold of those dies than having new ones made. If
3k thinks there is money to be made, the volume must be there.
I might sell a few of mine and buy a new truck!

I bought a 3K Model 52 magazine. It was terrible. I gave it to Keith Brown to see if he could make it work. I have all the 52, and 41 magazines I need. If you think that 41 magazines are high, try 41-1 (22 short). I have around 8 of those and I should sell some but their scarcity just wont let me do it!
 
I don't keep any magazines "loaded" except for my EDC pistol or home defense ones. All my none immediate use mags stay unloaded, but that's just me. I do have some extra training mags for my current EDC pistol, but those are only used for practicing quick(er) reloads. At a minimum I like having 3 mags for each pistol. More is better but not required.

Rick H.
 
I shot a S&W model 52-1 in competition for many seasons. I always took three magazines and used two, the third being for a problem with a magazine. I never needed the spare. I never took a bunch of loaded magazines for the 900 course. I would have probably ended up loading an empty magazine at one time or another for sustained fire and lost 50 points! I adhered to the KISS princlple.
 
One magazine is a "Barney mag". It is used to put one in the chamber, so I do not have to top off the carry mag. Named after Barney Fife.

Well darn! That's a great method. In many years of shooting, that never occured to me. I've always fiddled around with a single mag.

It's a good day. I learned something!
 
I bought some used m52 mags in a lot. They are all in very nice shape 7 look like they never been in a gun. The were each stored
separately and heavy oiled. My question is, how many different series of 52 mags were made by S&W. I have 14 mags and they all have identical floor plate with S&W logo. 3 mags out of new batch have slightly smaller floor plate but still with S&W logo.
I’m aware 3k is selling aftermarkets, are these stamped with S&W.
I gobble up all the 52 and old model 41 mags I run across at a good price. From what I’m hearing on 3k mags I don’t want any.
Hoping I didn’t get slipped a Mickey.
Will you sell 2 -Smith&Wessn ,Model 52 Semi Auto magazines,shipped to an Australian gun dealer?Need them to shoot the Service Match at my club,MISC."In the land down under".Melbourne ,Victoria Australia, 3000
 
Back
Top