Likely a stupid question

BlackSky

Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2008
Messages
597
Reaction score
69
Location
Sonoma/Marin Counties, CA
It sounds stupid to me when I say the question but what the hell. I'd like to be sure of the answer.

Are there any semi-auto handguns that are made to shoot revolver ammunition?
 
Register to hide this ad
I'm not sure.. I know someone will correct me if I'm wrong....

I think there are Desert Eagle variants that will fire .357 and .44 mag. I don't know if they're still in production.

There are no stupid questions, as they say.
 
A bunch, I'm sure. Offhand, the Desert Eagle MkVII (.44 Magnum) comes to mind; also the Mk XIX in .357 Magnum, .41 Magnum and .44 Magnum. LAR Grizzly (in .357 Magnum) is also out there, but in much smaller numbers.
 
Last edited:
I believe the Air Force is correct. Those are the only two production guns I can think of. There may have been a wildcat or two, but nothing comes to mind.
 
Smith and Wesson made a semi auto target pistol chambered for the 38 Special. I believe it was a model 52. IMI makes Desert Eagles that are chambered for 357 as well as 44 magnum. Almost every one who makes a semi auto makes one chambered for 22 Long Rifle, which is a rimmed cartridge, and might qualify for what you are referring to as a revolver cartridge.
 
"Current production" being the key words there. I still see Coonan 357's on the tables a gun shows occasionally.

The Desert Eagle is the only production gun that ever made a real place for itself, and though I'll probably get slammed for it (hey, I've owned a couple . . . but then I've owned just about everything at one time or another :D) I still consider the 'Eagles to be "novelties".

And oh yeah, the S&W 52 target wad gun. Some folks converted their Colts to do much the same thing with poor results - no production guns from "my little pony", though.
 
Huh, cool. Thanks for the info guys. The DE357 looks cool and would totally fit the bill. Unfortunately it's not on the CA DOJ Approved List. That means I have to find a private party willing to sell locally. Might take some time but I'll give it a shot.
 
Past and present ... yes ... I think it was the Coonan that would eat 38 spec and 357
DE will munch on 357 and 44 mag
I am certain their are others as well
 
Not sure what your objective is, but if you are wanting to achieve revolver ballistics in a semi-auto, there are several guns chambered in .357 SIG and 10mm that come very close.

In addition, they feed reliably, which has not always been the case with several semi-autos chambered for rimmed revolver cartridges.
 
Last edited:
"Not sure what your objective is..."

I currently have only revolvers. I want to add 1 semi-auto to the group (preferably not a small caliber) but don't want to have to stock a new ammo type. 357 is already in my inventory so a semi-auto for that caliber would be perfect.
 
"Not sure what your objective is..."

I currently have only revolvers. I want to add 1 semi-auto to the group (preferably not a small caliber) but don't want to have to stock a new ammo type. 357 is already in my inventory so a semi-auto for that caliber would be perfect.


Well, if you are used to revolver reliability and simplicity, I hope you are not disappointed. Several of the semi-autos chambered for revolver cartridges were jam-o-matics.
At best, they are more picky about their ammo than semi-autos chambered for rimless cartridges.
 
"Not sure what your objective is..."

I currently have only revolvers. I want to add 1 semi-auto to the group (preferably not a small caliber) but don't want to have to stock a new ammo type. 357 is already in my inventory so a semi-auto for that caliber would be perfect.

The Desert eagle fits your needs.
 
SW Model 52 in 38spl I want one !!!!

http://www.shootingtimes.com/handgun_reviews/ST_swmodel5238_200906/

ST_swmodel5238_200906-A.jpg


Introduced in 1961, the .38-caliber S&W Model 52 was one of the premier American-made centerfire target pistols.

For the first 60 years of the 20th century, handgun target shooting in the United States was relatively simple. Those shooters who participated in rimfire matches generally used a high-end Smith & Wesson or Colt revolver. Then, towards the end of the period, a certain percentage of shooters came to favor semiauto pistols.

Among the centerfire fraternity, the situation was even simpler. Except for the limited number of military and civilian shooters who participated in the National Matches and were thus required to use the .45-caliber Model 1911 pistol, just about every paper puncher of note was shooting a premium-grade Smith & Wesson or Colt revolver chambered for the .38 Special Mid-Range target wadcutter cartridge. These target revolvers had been perfected over the previous decades to the point where they provided all of the accuracy one could possibly desire, and as has been the wont of shooters over the centuries, the paper punchers saw no reason to mess with success. But things were about to change.

Beginning in 1946, S&W's president, C.R. Hellstrom, embarked upon a program to improve and modernize the company's production facilities and to develop new products for the civilian, military, and law enforcement markets. At the top of his must-do list was a modern, semiautomatic pistol that utilized a double-action/single-action trigger mechanism and was chambered for the 9mm Parabellum cartridge.

The task of designing the new pistol was assigned to the company's chief designer, Joseph Norman, who completed a prototype by October 1948. Known as the X-46, it combined a Browning tilting-barrel lockup system with a DA/SA trigger and a hammer-drop safety. Rotating the slide-mounted safety lever downward interposed a steel bar between the hammer and the firing pin before tripping the sear, releasing the hammer to move forward. A short, inertia-type firing pin permitted moving the safety lever "Off" so the pistol could be carried safely with the hammer down, yet it could be fired without having to manipulate any controls.

Smith & Wesson provided samples of the new pistol to the U.S. Army for trials, but the military quickly lost interest and let the project drop. Smith & Wesson continued development and released the new 4-inch-barreled pistol in 1959 as the Model 39.

In 1960, the U.S. Army Marksmanship Training Unit was so impressed with the performance of the Model 39, it requested that Smith & Wesson produce a similar model chambered for a proprietary cartridge it had developed, the .38 AMU, which was little more than the .38 Spl. Mid-Range wadcutter load but using a semirimless case. The new pistol was designated as the Model 52A, and approximately 90 pistols were delivered. They were used by the Army's pistol team for a short time.

S&W saw possibilities for this type of pistol, and in 1961, the company released it on the commercial market as the Model 52. It was similar to the Army pistol, except it was fitted with a longer, 5-inch barrel, used a setscrew to lock out the double-action option on the trigger, and it was chambered for the standard .38 Spl. Mid-Range wadcutter cartridge.

more here
http://www.shootingtimes.com/handgun_reviews/ST_swmodel5238_200906/
 
Yep

It sounds stupid to me when I say the question but what the hell. I'd like to be sure of the answer.

Are there any semi-auto handguns that are made to shoot revolver ammunition?

YEP:rolleyes:
YEP:rolleyes:

Sorry couldn't help myself.:D
 
Current production or ever, you weren't clear.

Besides what have been mentioned Colt made Gold Cups in .38 Special.

Current production includes Walther, Hammerli, and at least one other European manufacturer still building target semi-automatics chambered for .32 S&W Long Wadcutter.
 
IDK about the accuracy of it but i have HEARD that glock made a model WAY back that ate .38 spl, never did any research as I hate glocks but it could be fun to find out
 
Back
Top