I believe Stolen Valor is only an offense if you are using it for monetary gain....but I thought behavior such as this was illegal under "stolen valor"...I had heard this was overturned. Do any of you have the answer on that?
Honestly, I think the military went easy on him as he doesn't exactly look like he's playing with a full deck. The MP's were there and I don't think any of us were. If he was of sound mental state (anyone know a poser who is?) then he probably would've been a "very clumsy person who keeps running into brick walls and falling down" while on base.
Not surprisingly the (I think) 9th Circuit Court struck down Stolen Valor as an infringement of freedom of expression -- lying, they said, is a protected from of freedom of speech. And, in the instance of "social lies" I have to agree with them. I think a more carefully worded law -- Stolen Valor MkII ? -- is what's needed. Either that, or there should be no legal penalty for beating the **** out of those who do steal the valor of those who serve in the military. Either way, I'd be happy, and the "social lies" would soon stop.I believe Stolen Valor is only an offense if you are using it for monetary gain.