Good Youth Deer Rifle & Shotgun?

B

BillK01

Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2012
Messages
561
Reaction score
372
Location
Pittsburgh, PA
Been thinking of getting my oldest boy a good starter deer rifle & shotgun.

He's going to be 9 years old and is about average size for his age (or slightly below). He shoots my M & P 15/22 like a champ and has a Gamo Lil Cat pellet rifle and a Daisy Red Ryder that he's a great shot with. He can shoot both irons and optics easily. He's also shot my M & P 22 pistol a few times with help - but he's obviously still too small for a pistol.

I've asked him about shooting my M & P 15 TS a few times at the range but he's been hesitant and I don't want to push it. I think it's mainly because of the noise factor.

Anyway - been looking at the Compact models of the Remington 700, Ruger American and Savage in possibly .223, .243 or 25-06 (leaning toward a .243 but open to suggestions). I'm pretty clueless on a 20ga. shotgun and I'm not even sure he'd be able to shoot a shotgun at this point because of the recoil - even with a 20ga.

Just looking for some suggestions - probably won't do this until after his 9th birthday in Feb. Planning on getting him a PA Mentor License and taking him spring turkey hunting this coming year - and if that goes well possibly on the youth/mentor deer season later on.

Thanks in advance for any and all suggestions!

Bill
 
Register to hide this ad
Savage makes some pretty decent priced 7.62x39 chambered rifles that would be good on deer and easy on recoil. The new Mossberg and Rossi .30-30's get good reviews but I would avoid the new Marlins in favor of a good older used model. I know nothing about shotguns. And every boy should grow up with a 10/22!
 
Maximumbob54 said:
Savage makes some pretty decent priced 7.62x39 chambered rifles that would be good on deer and easy on recoil. The new Mossberg and Rossi .30-30's get good reviews but I would avoid the new Marlins in favor of a good older used model. I know nothing about shotguns. And every boy should grow up with a 10/22!
Click to expand...

Thanks! I have a 10/22 - however it's a tiny bit too big for him right now. The 15-22 with collapsable stock fits well. It's funny - he is more interested "cowboy" style guns than my AR variants. For his "own" .22 I was leaning toward a Henry Golden Boy youth model maybe.
 
I am not a fan of the switch barrel, break open guns but they are an option if you are on a tight budget. A 20 gauge and a 243 are really hard to beat, so I would try a Remington or Mossberg youth model pump and a youth model bolt action but stay away from the dirt cheap Savage/Mossy/Remington rifles. Ruger American, Howa, Remington 700, and Weatherby Vanguard are pretty darn good rifles for not much money and if he shows a real interest in hunting and shooting when he is older then maybe get him something more expensive.
 
Yea I really do like the Howa 2 in 1 youth package but I can't get over the "made in japan" thing. I know it's petty - especially since I have a Browning A-Bolt .300 win mag that's made in japan and a Glock 23 that's made in Austria - but I'd like to try to stick with an American made gun for him. Howa is still a good possibility though - that package is tough to beat.
 
Nothing smaller than a 243 for deer for me. Even that is marginal, in my opinion. There are a lot of options out there. I'd get something that can be used for a while, not just a cheapy
 
BillK01 said:
been looking at the Compact models of the Remington 700, Ruger American and Savage in possibly .223, .243 or 25-06
Click to expand...

Another scenario would be to buy the full size version of one of those, along with an inexpensive extra wooden stock. Cut down the extra stock and put a Pachmayr Decelerator pad on it for maximum recoil reduction. When he gets bigger, switch to the original, nicer looking standard stock.
 
Have you given any thought to a lever action 30-30? The recoil should not be a problem and the round has proven itself for quite a few years now. The rifles balance and handle nicely and you can shoot them as the come with iron sights or add optics.

Len
 
The Remington Model 1100 LT 20 gauge is a great youth shotgun. It has very light recoil. I do not know if Remington still makes them, but they must be available used.
 
My son started his oldest boy (who is about to turn 15 and now is 5'11") on an American-made (IIRC) switch-barrel combo in 20 gauge and .243. It proved a good stop on the way to man-sized guns, and the two younger boys are learning on it now.

I like the .243 for versatility. It's adequate for deer at reasonable ranges and deadly on varmints out to 400 yards or more.
 
I started with a 20 ga which I got for my 9th birthday and still hunt with the same gun today and I turn 70 in a few days. I have three other shotguns, all 20 ga. There is not a North American game bird I haven't taken with that original gun and that includes turkey and more geese than one could count.

A .243 is a very respectable game cartridge and will take any deer that roams this continent and with lighter bullets is a respectable varmint round as well. What is needed more than bullet diameter is the ability to judge distance and shoot well. And I guess with the new ranging scopes one doesn't even have to guess at distance. Be a marksman, don't attempt shots beyond your ability, learn where to put the bullet and the rest will take care of itself.
 
What about the thompson center gun company they have several long guns with interchangable barrels.

so for example if the rifle barrel is attached it can be removed and a shotgun barrel attached then it can be switched back.

Of course with that system the shooter only has one shot so the shooter would have to take their time and fire carefully.
 
I know someone said no cheapies,but look into the H&R.They make youth models in about all of their guns.If you can't find one you can buy the youth stock and switch it your self.243 or 7mm-08 would be a good rifle to start out and keep shooting for him.20 gauge will work too.Don't over look the single shots.I have 10 of the H&R singles,in various calibers, and love them all.From a 204 up to a 45-70.
 
Another vote for T/C.
I gotta admit to being biased though.
I learned to hunt with a single shot - BEST tool to teach a kid that the first shot's got to count.
I've done lever, semis, pumps, and bolts but for the last 10 years it's either been a 4" 686 or Contender carbine in 7-30 Waters depending on my mood at the time.
I also have a 22 match carbine barrel and although I've traded away all of my pistol barrels I still have the stocks.

IF I were in the market for a new gun I'd definitely buy a T/C Encore and start collecting barrels :)
 
I started off with a model94 (.25-35) with buckhorn sights. I understand the modern .30-30 has pretty good trajectory. Support the cowboy gun love.
Shotgun, model 1100 20ga. pretty soft recoil.(.410 is too hard to hit with, too expensive to feed etc.)
By the way, you're an awesome dad.
 
Last edited:
I would second the Remington 1100 in 20 gauge. They are very light in recoil (because they're gas-operated), and operate well in all conditions.

If he likes a lever-action, why not .44 Magnum or .45 Colt?
Indiana (for instance) requires pistol-size cartridges in deer season (actually they limit the case length) and a lot of handgun calibers are pretty effective (and very light in recoil) out of a rifle.

Straight-stick break-open single shot rifle/shotgun combos seem like a great idea when you shoot the rifle barrel. Not so much when you shoot the shotgun barrel.

I have a Rossi combo in .22LR and 20Ga. The 20 gauge kicks more than my 12 gauge.
 
9 year old boy... Hmmm... I'm assuming mass marketed rifles/shotguns here.

.243 Winchester, in a bolt action, my preference is a Winchester Model 70 featherweight. Either stainless or blued. Get an aftermarket stock until he grows into the adult version.

.257 Roberts is another goodie, IMHO. Probably a bit challenging to find ammo at your local WallyMart though.

.25-06, .270, .30-40, .30-06, get into what I'll call the Adult Recoil range.

.30-30 Winchester, in either a Winchester, Marlin, or Henry lever gun. Marlin makes a youth version, and if it's a recent production (2013) they have made big strides in quality control. Still not a JM, but hopefully improving. I would still want to inspect it first, rather than buy it online. This will be my grandson's first deer rifle when he comes of age (he's not even 3 yet). I've got a Remlin 336C in .30-30 all cleaned up and 'smoothe' waiting for him in the safe. Iron sights to start, optics after a few years of field experience.

.32 Winchester Special... Got my first deer with my grandmother's Marlin chambered in that caliber, so I gotta give it a mention.

Shotguns???

Way too much recoil with slugs, IMHO, for a 9 year old. I have an old 20 gauge single shot JC Higgins, that I tried some slugs in. It dang near brought tears to my eyes. And that was through a heavy wool coat. If you must go sluggin', I'd look for a Marlin 512 or 512P. These are heavy bolt action 12 gauge shotguns. One round in the chamber, two in the magazine. I would (and on mine have) consider some sort of recoil management device, such as a GraCoil, et al.

Good luck and thanks for keeping the hunting heritage alive!!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

CH4
Deer Hollow Enterprises
Replies
5
Views
531
boykinlp
boykinlp
M
Picked Up A Project Shotgun
Replies
10
Views
820
merl67
M
THE PILGRIM
Evans Rifle
Replies
4
Views
558
Ivan the Butcher
I
Glenn R. McMannly
My Finest Rifle
Replies
19
Views
1K
6string
6string
R
$89 New Shotgun
2
Replies
38
Views
2K
THE PILGRIM
THE PILGRIM

Latest posts

Back
Top