Different strokes for different folks. My number was 2927 and I got a service grade. Colt lower on a Colt slide from the 50’s. Reparked for sure but Uncle Sam reparked it so it is all GI to me. I wouldn’t have wanted one with all that finish gone. It’s like the M1’s I got from the CMP, I like character and the dings tell a story, but I would not have been happy with a rifle with most of its finish gone.
Those who got a CMP 1911 were not looking for a shooter. I fired 50 rounds through mine and cleaned it. Don’t see me putting more than 100 rounds a year through it. I have other guns to launch 230 grain .45 ACP bullets into paper with. I bought this and my M1’s for the history and quite frankly the value. They’re only going to go up. My first CMP M1 was $675 a few years ago. Try to get them for that. Buying an Auto Ordnance or Springfield GI clone would not scratch that itch to own a piece of history. I was offered $1500 for my reparked mixmaster the day I picked it up. Guy in the shop offered it to me right in the spot. I declined of course.
Agreed 100% on the bold, I'd just disagree with the categorization of which is a shooter. A 70s refurb mixmaster will have less collectors interest than a correct (or correct enough) WW2 been there-done that non-refurb, at least for now and watching 1911 sale prices on the popular sites. I'm absolutely not afraid to put a decent round count through mine as it's a less interesting pistol (my opinion only of course) than one that survived mostly as-issued (I'd still shoot just about any I got from the CMP, who am I kidding).
Granted, a great condition correct one will blow the worn one out of the water price wise.
As far as the reselling of 1911s being addressed, I can't care less. I've seen plenty of people have these for months now, and I'd imagine some of those people have needed cash for medical bills, car repairs, or other less fun guns. The CMP exists to promote civilian marksmanship and firearms competition, not to ensure we all get our birthright 1911 or Garand, and by selling these at a fair price they do that. I bought a used pickup awhile back well under market, didn't like it, and resold it at market price. I felt no guilt about that, nor would I about selling one of these if I had to at fair market price.
To those who don't like the price on the resell, I'd ask that if you feel honor bound to sell for what you paid to please drop me a line and I'll cover the interest too
