357PD (41 Mag)

Originally posted by tulsamal:


It is an interesting gun. If it had been available without a lock, I might well have bought one.

Gregg

Mine is the only Smith I own with an IL. It has a very nice double action trigger, and I am getting used to the look of the sleeved barrel.

I may one day own another IL gun if they come out with a 5" 657 with the Mountain Gun tapered barrel. I'm not holding my breath though.
 
I almost bought a 415 but the lock hole in the hammer turned me off of it, not that it had a hole just that it was in the hammer. I did eventually buy a pre lock 445. The quality isn't up to par with the older Taurus revolvers I have but it is still a good gun. My only negative is the lack of after market grips available for it.

SuperMan, I bought an old Lee mould for a .41 years ago and their was a sheet in it that listed the moulds at the time. There were three wadcutters and two round nose versions with various weights plus a couple of SWCs. I don't know how but I eventually ended up with one of each. I also have the more recent moulds by RCBS and Lyman and a couple of others. The best part of the Lee moulds is there is nothing that I've ever found that has data for them. I get to figure it out for myself.
icon_wink.gif
There is a 192 gr. RN that works well in the .41AE too.
 
I don't like the IL on the 357 either but since there was no choice I just bought it. I only have three IL guns..the 357, a 686 .38 Super and a 4" M500.

RGS and I participated in a Lee mold group buy over on the Cast Bullet Forum. The first was a 260 grain Keith bullet and the other I think is a 170 Keith. The 260 came in a few weeks ago and the 170 will be here in probably August. I am going out to visit RGS is a few weeks and maybe we can cast up some bullets...

Bob
 
Originally posted by SuperMan:
I don't like the IL on the 357 either but since there was no choice I just bought it. I only have three IL guns..the 357, a 686 .38 Super and a 4" M500.

RGS and I participated in a Lee mold group buy over on the Cast Bullet Forum. The first was a 260 grain Keith bullet and the other I think is a 170 Keith. The 260 came in a few weeks ago and the 170 will be here in probably August. I am going out to visit RGS is a few weeks and maybe we can cast up some bullets...

Bob



To tell you the truth I think I have 2 more molds coming, but I can't remember what the last one is. Does a 230gr Keith ring a bell?
 
SuperMan:

RE
..just for your information, IF they were still on the market the dealer wholesale would be $781.50...at $740.00 that is only $18.00 over what my wholesaler closed them out at when they were discontinued earlier this year.

...just went by there today...it's STILL THERE!!! Price may have been $749....

Still too much for me. I've grown really *in lust* with the 8-holers....
 
Just found a NIB Model 357PD at the local gun shop.
On layaway until the rest of the funds are found, can't wait to try it out. I'm sure it will have a bit more recoil than my Model 57.
 
I'm glad to see a thread dedicated for this fine revolver. I must say that I have enjoyed every round I have put through this gun since I picked it up. Here's me slingin' some lead at a local IDPA match.

IDPA_April_2009_025sized.jpg
 
The only thing I see slowing down any of the "New" S&Ws from selling better is the
hole in it's side. (Just a Fact)
The 41 Mag is still my favorite shooter.
BB
 
Originally posted by BuzzardBilly:
The only thing I see slowing down any of the "New" S&Ws from selling better is the
hole in it's side. (Just a Fact)
The 41 Mag is still my favorite shooter.
BB

Since I bought the 41 mag 357PD light weight revolver last year it has really grown on me. I mainly shoot mild reloads with Berry plated 210 gr bullets backed by 7 grains of Unique and I couldn't be happier with it.

Personally I don't fret about the internal lock. I removed the one on my 357PD and put the cursed little parts in a small plastic zip-lock bag for prosterity.

Zip-lock bags are a good idea. The S&W internal lock is a bad idea.
 
No disrespect meant...
It's just a cosmetic "pimple" to me.
In reality I want one, just too pig-headed to
bite the bullet.
Enjoy,
BB
 
I own a S&W 57 Mountain Gun, which is about as much "bang for the buck" that I can prsonally stand. The concept of the 357PD is appealing. The light weight is appealing. An ucontrollable gun is not appealing. What is the point if you cant put the bullets where they need to go? If you really are superman, then it doesnt mater. If you have a hard time firing 100 44 Mags out of a standard weight gun and not ending up with a flinch, then you may have an issue with this gun.If you have nerves of steel, this is the gun for you.
 
Gents,

I ordered one of these for my brother-in-law. It's a pretty incredible revolver. Extremely well made, accurate, and a joy to carry. He uses it as his primary CCW pistol with proper ammunition, of course. It's .44 Mag counterpart is a peach, too.
Hard cast bullets at about 1,000 FPS are managable and give you about all the power you need. Full power loads can be a bit of a problem recoil wise, but with practice can be mastered.
I'd put one of these on my "must have" 'Smith list.

Try a Don Hume Model 721 OT (open top) for concealed carry or their 720 with safety strap for field use. Excellent leather and a reasonable cost.

Wes
 
Originally posted by caribouhunter:
Looking for carry holster suggestions for the 357PD. Anyone here carry this gun and has a good holster they would recommend?

I use the DeSantis Speed Scabbard when I do carry the gun...

Since it has been a while since this post "ended" I also picked up a very rare Taurus Titanium Tracker with a 6" barrel. A very good shooter for such a light gun...

Distance was 15 yards double action with a 210 Berry's plated bullet powered by 8 grains of Unique..about 1000 fps from a 6" gun.. The target on the left was shot slow fire and the right target shot as soon as I could get the sights back on target...

SWenraved57s001.jpg


With a 4" Ti Tracker and a stainless 4"..

SWenraved57s003.jpg


Great caliber and great guns...Bob
 
Originally posted by Eliakim:
Does anybody know why these things aren't selling well enough to remain in production? It seems to me to be a perfect balance of power and portability for a woods gun.

It was the only S&W with an internal lock that I was ever seriously tempted to buy. Why else would they discontinue it?
icon_rolleyes.gif
 
Love the .41 mag. Have 3 of them with a 3", 4' and 6 " barrel. Have heard of problems with the two piece barrels. Myself find the recoil on mine very easy to handle compared to my .44 mags.

BTW my old 6" model has 37 deer to it's name. Mostly Sitka Blacktails from living on Kodiak and Baranof Islands while in the Coast Guard for 7 years.

I occasionnally carry the 3" Lew Horton with 210 gr. SGD's in the winter for a CCW. If it'll take a deer with ease it makes me feel very secure in it's ablilty to protect me from evil.

This is a round to reload. Try using some lead SWC's in a light load. Very enjoyable, accurate and easier on the wallet.


Enjoy it!
 
Hey guys, there are some things to understand about guns. The 357 is just a brother to the M57, or the M29, or the M27, or the 329, the list is nearly endless. The general rule (but not conclusive) is its just another N frame with a 4" barrel. Don't buy leather blindly. Take the gun you want to use it with along when you go leather buying. Test it.

With the new and awful fiber optic front sights, pay particular attention to how it comes out of the holster. After that, you're good to go usually.

More specific to the M357 is the idea with all .41 Magnums. Its a handloaders caliber, much in the same vein as the .22 Jets. You can own and shoot one without loading for it, but you end up not enjoying all its capabilities. Many of us who own .41s never shoot factory ammo. Yes, we have a few boxes hidden in our junk. It never occurs to us to use it. Reloads are so much more versatile, its the order of the day.

Back to leather... One thing to keep in mind with the Scandium guns is they're so light, the holsters we originally bought for steel N's often make you wonder if you lost the gun. Many of us own (I'm wearing one as I type) big thick leather belts. We bought them to properly support a 3# crew served M29 or M57. The lightweight guns just vanish when you're used to lugging heavyweights around.
 
Back
Top