model 60 Pro or Sig P938

Rivers2k · Jul 5, 2023

My first handgun was a 442 which I traded for a .22lr sp101 so I am familiar with j frames but it has been about 15 years since owning one. I came across the Model 60 Pro Series in a shop a month ago and my goodness that trigger I cant stop thinking about it. that trigger is so crisp and light.

Due to a promise I made I would buy anymore this year with out selling one. This is where the p938 comes in. Its a fun gun carries easy but not that accurate 7 yards I am in the 10 ring 15 yard it really opens up I can keep all 7 shots on an 8" target but I really have to focus. 25 yards I am all on over the place can barely hit a silhouette target.

So any advice from some that has a model 60. Do you think it is more accurate or about the same. I am afraid I will regret a trade and not be able to go back if the accuracy isn't there. I know I have to do my part I am a fairly good shot but cant squeez much more out of my p938. Advice from someone that has had both would be really interesting to me.

tlawler · Jul 5, 2023

I bought a 938 for my wife a few years back. She never really warmed to it and I couldn’t hit anything past 15 yards with it. Neat little pistol, though, and I liked the looks of it. Ended up trading it towards something else I can’t remember. As far as revolvers, I naturally shoot them much better than just about any semi-auto I own. I don’t have a model 60, but have had a few .357 mag J-frames, and other than the air weights and ultralights, I could be pretty accurate out to 15 yards and keep them within a 12” circle out to 25 yards. My favorite was my 640-1 Pro. I was deadly with that! My daughter laid claim to it, but she still lets me shoot it when I go to visit her

texmex · Jul 6, 2023

Pro series. No magazines to mess with. In cool weather you can have the gun in your hand inside a coat pocket. The fastest draw is to already have the gun in your hand. Can be fired in the pockrpet and function normally, Bullet shape not a factor for the pro series plus more power,

scruffy · Jul 6, 2023

Pro Series 60 is a fine revolver. The 3" barrel and stock grips and exposed hammer may or may not be easy to conceal depending on your own build. clothing, etc. It is still limited to 5 shots. Can't comment on the P938, but I do have a standard Sig P365 which I carry when not carrying one of my 642 PC of 637 PC J-frames. Very concealable for pocket or IWB, choice of 10+1 or 12+1 magazines, 3.5 lb trigger, excellent night sights and most importantly I shoot it well and it has been 100% reliable with over 1,200 rounds of different types of factory ammo. Factor this with the Sigs modular approach where you can swap out frames, and slides in seconds. If you want a 9mm semi auto for CCW it's a great choice.

Rivers2k · Jul 6, 2023

scruffy said:
Pro Series 60 is a fine revolver. The 3" barrel and stock grips and exposed hammer may or may not be easy to conceal depending on your own build. clothing, etc. It is still limited to 5 shots. Can't comment on the P938, but I do have a standard Sig P365 which I carry when not carrying one of my 642 PC of 637 PC J-frames. Very concealable for pocket or IWB, choice of 10+1 or 12+1 magazines, 3.5 lb trigger, excellent night sights and most importantly I shoot it well and it has been 100% reliable with over 1,200 rounds of different types of factory ammo. Factor this with the Sigs modular approach where you can swap out frames, and slides in seconds. If you want a 9mm semi auto for CCW it's a great choice.

Thanks for the feed back. I do have larger hands, not huge but large glove size, and the 365 doesn't fit my hand right. Its the same problem I have with the p938.

colt_saa · Jul 6, 2023

So why not get another 640 Pro?

If you have a gun that you do not like or trust, then why keep it?

I love the J-frames, always have

I have been carrying a 2" J-frame almost every day of my life since 1980. It used to be my BUG, now it is my daily carry, primary personal defense firearm

These days it is mostly my Model 340 that resides in the pocket. If I use a belt holster or ankle rig, I go with a stainless version and that is usually a Model 60 Chiefs Special Target.

I just wish the Factory had brought out a 357 version of the 2" Model 60 CST.

While I am a BIG SIG fan as well (a P220 saved my life) I have never liked the 938. It's design so reminded me of that failed Colt 380. I tried one anyway and while it functioned better than the Colt it was copied from (a few improvements in the design) I was not pleased with it's performance so I never purchased one.

Unfortunately you live in New York or I would meet you at the range so that you can try a few Model 60s, including my 3" Pro

3rdgeargrndrr · Jul 6, 2023

Former P938 owner here. They can be very accurate guns but micros have their own nuances. Have a friend or a good shot shoot some self defense HP or otherwise good ammo thru it.
As with all guns and accuracy issues, I always suggest tightening the loose nut behind the trigger.

Rivers2k · Jul 6, 2023

3rdgeargrndrr said:
Former P938 owner here. They can be very accurate guns but micros have their own nuances. Have a friend or a good shot shoot some self defense HP or otherwise good ammo thru it.
As with all guns and accuracy issues, I always suggest tightening the loose nut behind the trigger.

That is true, mine p938 is more accurate with the hotter ammo, unfortunately that is the more expensive ammo

Rivers2k · Jul 6, 2023

colt_saa said:
So why not get another 640 Pro?

If you have a gun that you do not like or trust, then why keep it?

Very good point. I am just worried I will drop some money on another gun and not be happy with it. I am trying to manager my expectations before deciding to purchase or not. P938 trade in near me at several shops is only giving $400 on a trade which isn't bad since I paid $600. But I have to come up with another $450 cash so that is why I am looking for information like what you provided.

If a model 60 preforms the same I would just stick with the p938. I also don't carry often. Really just when I am on hikes. from what I am reading sounds like the model 60 might preform a little better. Would love to see some targets from range trips.

mikerjf · Jul 6, 2023

Autos are preferable for serious work for many reasons; capacity, reload speed, and lower recoil among them.

Having said that, the J frame resides at a sweet spot of convenience, capability, reliability, and safety. It also makes a great backup.

Best answer is to have a bigger auto (more capable than a 938), and ALSO have a J frame for lower-threat times and/or backup use.

Rivers2k · Jul 6, 2023

mikerjf said:
Autos are preferable for serious work for many reasons; capacity, reload speed, and lower recoil among them.

Having said that, the J frame resides at a sweet spot of convenience, capability, reliability, and safety. It also makes a great backup.

Best answer is to have a bigger auto (more capable than a 938), and ALSO have a J frame for lower-threat times and/or backup use.

I do have other larger handguns. This is just to fill the niche of light summer CCW. something accurate out to 25 yards.

Really looking for the answer to the question will the model 60 be more accurate than the 938 in the hands of the same shooter. looking for more accuracy from 15-25 yards.

I am also not worried about "serious work" I have never had an issue more worried about rabid coyotes, and dogs while on hikes. Those have been more of an issue in my area.

ultratec00 · Jul 6, 2023

I have a 938 as well. Fine firearm but my Kimber Micro 9s are what get carried. Remarkably accurate and reliable. My 642 has long since been retired.

Notime2 · Jul 6, 2023

I was looking for a 938 when the gun store reminded me of the 7 round capacity, all because of heart failure and the doctor nicked a tendon when he inserted the catheter in my right wrist, made my 642 difficult to reload during drills. Ended up with the 365xl and purchased a Wilson grip. These are the 2 guns Hickok 45 would never sell! My opinion also. Notime 2 also with large hands.

UncleEd · Jul 6, 2023

Stop thinking 15 and 25 yards.
Realistically a SD gun is needed at
much closer range.

It's all what one is most comfortable with
in the revolver vs. auto debate. Firepower
is secondary.

Small autos are always more prone to
jamming than their bigger counterparts.

Small revolvers, big revolvers, their
reliability rate is probably the same.

sophie · Jul 6, 2023

I gave my youngest son my Sig P938 years ago. I never liked it because it wasn’t a good fit for me.
I still have a couple of S&W Model 60’s w/2” barrel. I don’t carry them.
Like mentioned above, the Sig P365 was the answer for me. More capacity, lighter, and more accurate for me. I carry the Sig P365 for the last 5 years.

ultratec00 · Jul 7, 2023

Times have changed and one can mostly keep themselves out of harms way by simply following common sense and avoiding certain situations and/or scenarios.

What can't be accounted for is the active shooter encountered at a public venue. I would much rather be prepared knowing whatever firearm is being carried will be effective at intermediate distances. Effective, and shooter accurate, enough to deal with that particular threat and have some chance of surviving.

UncleEd said:
Stop thinking 15 and 25 yards.
Realistically a SD gun is needed at
much closer range.

Rivers2k · Jul 7, 2023

ultratec00 said:
Times have changed and one can mostly keep themselves out of harms way by simply following common sense and avoiding certain situations and/or scenarios.

What can't be accounted for is the active shooter encountered at a public venue. I would much rather be prepared knowing whatever firearm is being carried will be effective at intermediate distances. Effective, and shooter accurate, enough to deal with that particular threat and have some chance of surviving.

My thoughts exactly. There was a person that stopped an active shooter in texas and he was an instructor said you should practice being able to hit a paper plate at 25 yards.

To be completely honest I don't carry much but at the range I do practice that 25 yards drill.

I want all my guns to be capable of hitting a paper plate at 25 yards. Currently all my guns do except my p938. I wonder if a model 60 pro can.

3rdgeargrndrr · Jul 7, 2023

Rivers2k said:
That is true, mine p938 is more accurate with the hotter ammo, unfortunately that is the more expensive ammo

Then I would just know where it shot and practice with cheap ammo knowing it is what it is. Shoot drills with the cheap stuff as long as the general aim is the same.

Rivers2k said:
My thoughts exactly. There was a person that stopped an active shooter in texas and he was an instructor said you should practice being able to hit a paper plate at 25 yards.

To be completely honest I don't carry much but at the range I do practice that 25 yards drill.

I want all my guns to be capable of hitting a paper plate at 25 yards. Currently all my guns do except my p938. I wonder if a model 60 pro can.

Different schools of thought on this topic.
If you are in a predictable area where you will be the defense for the flock, then you carry a full size and reloads. (The church gun)
If you are out and about, and need comfort&concealment and something that gets you out of dodge, carry what suits you. (The micro)

CQB60 · Jul 14, 2023

Between your choices, the P938. But I agree with the P365 remarks stated here. An Easy carry as well as is the P938. Good luck

Shibadog · Aug 3, 2023

I have both a P938 and a model 60 Pro (3”). Both good pistols. I can shoot the 60 better than the 938. A big plus, to me anyway, is a revolvers versatility ammo wise. My 60 has used everything from shot loads, to .38 Target to mild .357 to some fairly heavy .357’s depending on what I was doing at the time. Full boat .357’s aren’t enjoyable (to me) in a J frame, BUTthey bring a lot of hp for when it’s needed.

model 60 Pro or Sig P938

Member

US Veteran

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Similar threads