The most accurate Smith & Wesson auto...

bc1023

Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2013
Messages
822
Reaction score
3,967
Well, I’m not sure about all that, but it sure sounds good. ;)

10 to 15 years ago, Smith & Wesson’s Performance Center was all about performance. These pistols were purpose built for the ultimate in accuracy, speed, smoothness, and reliability. The guns were tightly hand fit using high quality parts throughout their construction. A gold colored Briley bushing locked everything down up front and kept the bullets flying exactly where they’re aimed. Today, the Performance Center exists by name only and not by performance, function, or quality.

One of the earliest examples of the performance center auto was a pistol based on the incredibly sturdy 5906 platform. This pistol took the platform and accurized it to the extreme, installed the original Performance Center single action trigger (from the 845), improved and lengthened the barrel, and installed new target sights from Aristocrat. This gun was built specifically for Police Pistol Combat competition and was sold to law enforcement only. It was simply called the 5906 PPC or PPC9 for short.

The spent case states that it was built in 2004. This gun came with the soft case and Nill grips, which was different than the earlier iterations of the pistol. I think its a great looking handgun. They aren’t quite as pretty as the more common single stack 952 (which utilizes the same design), but they feel better my hands. The PPC9's double stack grip fills my palm better and they don’t have a grip safety. I also love the combination of the grip stippling and the checkering on the front strap.

This example is in great shape. It was used in competition a bit, so it shows some holster wear towards the front of the slide and front of the trigger guard, but the stainless makes it easy to buff out. The Nill grips are in perfect shape. The mag well shows a few handling marks from slamming the mags home at speed, but not bad. Overall, the gun is in excellent condition and I can’t wait to put a few rounds through it. :cool:

Is it the most accurate Smith & Wesson pistol? I obviously can’t say. However, I would not be surprised if it turns out to be one of my most accurate, if not my most accurate pistol from any manufacturer. Its a thoroughbred of design and purpose and undoubtedly one of the most accurate American built pistols in history. I’ve seen accuracy tests in which this gun really outperformed even the best 1911s, so we will see how it does in my hands. :)























Here are all my PC autos together (I kept my PC1911 out)

845, PPC9, PPC9 6", 952-2 6", 952-1, 945, Comp 40


 
Register to hide this ad
Thank you for sharing your wonderful collection of Performance Center semis. I've never even seen most of the guns in your group photo. And I was surprised to see the Nill stocks. I have Nills on my HK P7 and they are beautiful as well as functional. Again, fantastic collection!
 
I appreciate your understated description. To my eye it looks much better than "great looking" and "great shape". Perhaps exceptional? Thanks for sharing a unique and beautiful firearm.

It would be interesting, but difficult and time consuming, to compare the accuracy of various center fire pistols. It looks like you have some good tools to start that testing.
 
Last edited:
I appreciate your understated description. To my eye it looks much better than "great looking" and "great shape". Perhaps exceptional? Thanks for sharing a unique and beautiful firearm.

It would be interesting, but difficult and time consuming, to compare the accuracy of various center fire pistols. It looks like you have some good tools to start that testing.

Thank you for the kind words. I do perform some accuracy bench testing with various centerfire target pistols.

The vast majority of my target/sporting pistols are European.
 
Nice gun and sweet collection. I'd enjoy a chance to just shoot the PPC9.
 
Anyone who remembers the model 52 can attest to its accuracy. Mine was way more accurate than I was able to shoot it, but put in the hands of an expert I am confident in saying that it was and is the most accurate semi-auto that S&W ever built. It would pretty much shame anything that came out of the PC now or in the past.
 
Anyone who remembers the model 52 can attest to its accuracy. Mine was way more accurate than I was able to shoot it, but put in the hands of an expert I am confident in saying that it was and is the most accurate semi-auto that S&W ever built. It would pretty much shame anything that came out of the PC now or in the past.

I don't think so, personally.

I've had a 52 for years. It doesn't outshoot my best PC autos. It's accurate, no doubt, but people tend to get a bit carried away, in my opinion.
 
Last edited:
Interestingly enough, my 6+ hour range day yesterday had both a phenomenal 52-2 and, believe it or not... a 6" S&W PPC9. And I can tell you that pitting these two against each other not only makes for one fantastic range day, but I honestly think it makes for a very interesting and spirited debate.

Personally, I would suggest that some questions can't be reliably answered. What I mean is that you could compare two models (for example, 6" PPC9 and Model 52) and you could test them in multiple ways AND you could probably come to a firm and scientific conclusion. But then I say... if you took FIVE examples of a 6" PPC9 and FIVE examples of a 52, would all five of one outclass all five of the other?

Terrific pistol, OP. It is one of my ultimate dream guns. Easy to say that about one you show off given your collection, but it truly is for me.
 
The S&W M41 also deserves to be held at a very high standard also. Definitely a competitive shooting handgun as well.
 
Haha! I had my 745 on the range day also! :)
I totally love that pistol, but I don't ask it for precision, slow fire target work. For dumping dozens of steel plates, it is one of my most often used pistols.
 
Haha! I had my 745 on the range day also! :)
I totally love that pistol, but I don't ask it for precision, slow fire target work. For dumping dozens of steel plates, it is one of my most often used pistols.

Yeah, I think it was Smith & Wesson's first single action 45ACP auto. The 645 was their first 45ACP auto.
 
This thread needed to be bumped for discussion. I think we've got more active and recent Performance Center fans, owners and shooters active recently.

I believe in the hands of the BEST shooter, the 52 is going to beat out the 952/PPC-9 in a Bullseye competition if "all else is equal", which is obviously a difficult task.

I've shot some inspiring groups with my 52-2 and an equal number of shoddy ones. Okay, I've definitely shot more lousy ones. ;) I totally love my PC 9mm guns but I feel like it's going to be an uphill battle to squeeze the best from them.

For a cash money or bragging rights showdown, my 952 stays on the table... my 52-2 stays on the table... my PPC-9 stays on the table and my Performance Center 845 Limited is ready on the firing line! :D
 
Sevens, you have a beautiful collection. Thinking about testing the 952 waters, but yikes - the price of admission is steep. Have a 52-2 and love it - no pc guns yet though, and your threads are tempting me. Any thoughts on a 952-1 vs. 952-2? From what I’ve seen recently, some big price differences.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top