-
Forum Update: We've upgraded the software to improve security, performance, and the overall experience.
👉 Read why we made the change | Support the Forum
19-3 vs 28-2
- Thread starter Rockets
- Start date
Register to hide this ad
The heavier N frame 28-2 will be more pleasant to shoot .357's than the K frame 19, but not as practical for carry use. Depending on condition, $450 is probably pretty fair.
Todd
Todd
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2007
- Messages
- 27,660
- Reaction score
- 21,272
It depends on condition, but if it is nice (98%) $450 is probably at the high end of current sales prices. In my opinion there is a big difference between the two in handling; the N frame feels too big for me. Perhaps your friend will let you try both side-by-side with similar loads, and you can decide from there?
OP
Rockets
Member
- Joined
- Feb 27, 2011
- Messages
- 251
- Reaction score
- 52
The 28-2 feels perfect in my hands....He's in a jam and I am trying to help him. I'll follow your advice and go to the range next week to try it his 19-3
Jack Flash
SWCA Member
It all depends on the M19's condition. Mechanically and cosmetically I would want NRA Very Good or better.
Having said that, I have seen some pretty beat up (but mechanically sound) M19s at gun shops in my area with an asking price of $500. And they sold at that price, too.
An M19 is obviously smaller, lighter, and handier than an M28. Conventional wisdom is that they will not hold up as well to a steady diet of full-power magnums as an M-28 will, but it may take a heck of a lot of shooting to prove that point.
For me, N-Frames take a little getting used to. But they are well worth it, especially if you want to transition to .44 / .45 caliber rounds, since they are pretty much the only game in town.
In your shoes I would go ahead and buy the M19, assuming condition is as previously mentioned. See how you like it. You can always sell it for about that much (or more) and they are nice guns in their own right. Who knows, you may like it better than the M28.
Having said that, I have seen some pretty beat up (but mechanically sound) M19s at gun shops in my area with an asking price of $500. And they sold at that price, too.
An M19 is obviously smaller, lighter, and handier than an M28. Conventional wisdom is that they will not hold up as well to a steady diet of full-power magnums as an M-28 will, but it may take a heck of a lot of shooting to prove that point.
For me, N-Frames take a little getting used to. But they are well worth it, especially if you want to transition to .44 / .45 caliber rounds, since they are pretty much the only game in town.
In your shoes I would go ahead and buy the M19, assuming condition is as previously mentioned. See how you like it. You can always sell it for about that much (or more) and they are nice guns in their own right. Who knows, you may like it better than the M28.
Revolver-time
Member
I have both exept my 19-3 is a 6". I like my 28 better. The 19 seems perhaps "delicate". Maybe I am just a N frame guy.
stevieboy
Member
The bottom line is that the 28 is a superb gun for shooting magnums but a bear to carry. The 19 functions much better as a carry piece but doesn't handle the snap of a magnum round nearly as well as does the 28.
I love shooting magnums but I don't love getting my hand/wrist beaten up by recoil. That's why I shoot magnum rounds exclusively from my Models 27 and 28. I never shoot anything more robust than .38 +P from my 19 and 66 even though both guns are rated for magnum rounds.
I love shooting magnums but I don't love getting my hand/wrist beaten up by recoil. That's why I shoot magnum rounds exclusively from my Models 27 and 28. I never shoot anything more robust than .38 +P from my 19 and 66 even though both guns are rated for magnum rounds.
Pass on the 19 and just buy another 28. They will shoot light loads as
well or better than the 19. The 28 may be the best gun for the money
that S&W ever made.
well or better than the 19. The 28 may be the best gun for the money
that S&W ever made.
Nanook 450
Member
If I'm carrying an N frame its a 44; shooting a 357 out of the K/L frame is nothing to manage, especially after shooting a few 44s.
If he's a friend and needs the help I'd do it. Even if the 450 is a little high (by bout 50 bucks in my area) the 19 is a good gun and nice to carry. I never enjoyed shooting full house loads through one though. If it is a matter of selling the 28 to buy the 19 I'd pass.
OP
Rockets
Member
- Joined
- Feb 27, 2011
- Messages
- 251
- Reaction score
- 52
You're a good friend.....congrats and let us all know how it shoots!
JCS&W
US Veteran
A friend has a M19-3 he wants to sell. Wants $450, unless it is a beater, that M19 would not last 10 minutes down here. Heck, I have seen good ones sell for over $550. I would buy it. I have both, and I have to admit I like the M28-2 better, but it is close. If it will make you feel better, tell your friend he can buy it back when he gets back on his feet, for the same price.
OP
Rockets
Member
- Joined
- Feb 27, 2011
- Messages
- 251
- Reaction score
- 52
jdickson397
Member
The price seems about right to me at least based on prices in the Southeast. Why not just shoot regular velocity 38 special loads in both guns but especially the Model 19? It saves money and saves wear and tear. You can always load up with magnum loads if needed for self defense purposes. Model 19's are really nice revolvers and you will enjoy shooting it.
rayb
US Veteran
Buy it and help your friend if your finances permit.
Shoot 38Special + P in it, or lower pressure .357's if you reload.
rayb
Shoot 38Special + P in it, or lower pressure .357's if you reload.
rayb
I was glad to hear you decided to help your friend out and buy the 19-3. I have both models and take them to the range together. I enjoy the differences each offers. My 28, 4", no dash, was my latest purchase. I love the feel of this piece. So much so, I know I will be picking up another in the future.
OP
Rockets
Member
- Joined
- Feb 27, 2011
- Messages
- 251
- Reaction score
- 52
Always good to have a "spare"
I am looking for a 27 or even another 28 if anyone knows or has one for sale pls pm @ [email protected]
