What I really have a problem with is that he told the OP that they were reblued - and tried to buy them at a price based on that lie. That, to me, is absolutely unethical. If he was knowledgeable, and I bet he was, he clearly saw to hard to find S&W revolvers possessed by someone who wasn't as knowledgeable as he was and he tried to steal them. Worse, he lied to do it.
People like that disgust me to my very core.
You should verify the 38 outdoorsman will not accept 357 shells. Some were converted to do so since the frame (N frame) can handle 357 mags.