Thanks for the thoughts, everyone. I snagged the 19 first and while they were writing it up, I said "screw it" and had them put the 686 on the order, too.
Too bad Washington screwed over all of us with CPLs last session so we can no longer take home handguns without a wait and background check. Cabelas won't release them until they get a positive "proceed" from the LE background check, even though State law does allow for them to deliver after a full 10 business days have passed without a "denied" response. It might be damn near Christmas before they get to come home.
I actually only have 3 .357s other than these...an Old Model Blackhawk, a Rossi lever gun and a S&W Model 28.
Rob