I agree. Since that load does not approach the pressures generated by a .357 Magnum load there is no reason not to shoot it in a .357 Magnum revolver.According to my RCBS Cast Bullet Manual #1, 1986 copyright that is a max load for .38 special (they specify CCI 250 magnum primer). A model 19 is designed for .357 magnum pressures which are nearly twice that of .38 special.