I have a M&P compact in .45ACP. I can't make a comparison, since I don't own the other two you mentioned,but I can say that the pisrol fits my medium size hand very well. The grip and barrel are both shorter than the full size pistol, and it shoots very well. There were some early problems with a mushy trigger, but I believe those have been worked out in current production. I can't think of any negatives to tell you about. It's an accurate, reliable handgun, and I don't think you could go wrong with one.