610 10mm/40S&W should I???

[DJINCO]

My wife is convinced that I need a new gun capable of shooting 40 S&W. Of course I must obey. I was considering a 4006, but I am not happy with the trigger and accuracy reports. I have a 5906 so I am aware of the trigger.

I really don't want a polymer gun so the M&P is a no go. I was considering a SIG 229 or 229. The options are vast and I am concerned that many feel that the "new" SIGs are not as "good" as the German SIGs. All of this for the better part of $1K.

Now here are the pros of 610

I love the frame as I have multiple 629's and a 625JM
I like the moon clips - easy to reload and no brass to chase
I already have the holsters
It can shoot 40 or 10mm - a plus for the mountains over the SIG

Cons
Six rounds vs 14 for the SIG SCT
Pretty heavy
Already have pretty much everything covered with a 44


Did I miss anything?

I think this is a good idea... what says the "brain trust"?

 

[Amici]

I had a 4006 - sold it without regrets then and would not get one now.

You could get a 1911 in .40 - it's THE caliber/design of choice for USPSA's Limited Division. Works well on steel, also.

Of course, getting the 610 means you could shoot in TWO divisions with the same ammo. Just load RNFP's; NOT SWC's!

 

[DJINCO]

I guess I should add that I don't like the 1911. I had a Kimber and it was a jam-o-matic.

I find no need for a safety.

I use a booger hook and brain safety. I don't like added "things" to get in the way if I need the gun.

 

[SW357Addict]

Definitely go with the 610 over an auto. It will be more reliable and revolvers are so much cooler than autos. In the 610, you can shoot both .40 and 10mm which you cannot do in an auto. Moonclips rock.

 

[DJINCO]

Thanks. I know that I don't need another 6xx but my wife of 30 years insists that I should have a gun capable of 40 S&W.

Why would I argue with my wife?

I guess this would make me an "NframeAddict"

 

[Aglifter]

While I further support the 610 idea, a newish Sig P226 isn't a bad choice -- I have one in 357 sig/40 S&W -- I like 357 Sig as a caliber, and w. some custom polishing work, the trigger feels as good as the old W. German ones.

For the weight, and the size, obviously you do get considerably more capacity from a semi -- I guess part of it is how much trouble you really expect. (EG, I'm perfectly happy w. my 329NG or 625 most of the time, but if I'm heading to some really bad parts of town, I carry my G29 or XD45... and usually both... and an SU-16 w. (10) 30-rd mags...

 

[DJINCO]

As the old saying goes...

If I was expecting trouble I would have brought a rifle.

I do have some Glocks when I need a wheel chock or a hammer.

 

[gagunner 2]

610!!!and you don't have to bend over looking for brass!!!

 

[Allen-frame]

610-

 

[Revolver King]

Go for the 610 and you will never look back. Now which one 4,5 or 6.5" barrel?

 

[TSQUARED]

I purchased a S&W 610 with the 4 inch barrel - a very versatile gun. You can load the 40 S&W as mild as a 9mm or more stout than a 45 ACP and anytyhing in between.

 

[colt_saa]

If you have your chambers lengthened, you will also be able to shoot 10MM Magnum from that model 610.

 

[Smee78]

If its a 40 you want, then get a 40. Don't forget about the 646.

 

[Amici]

I guess I should add that I don't like the 1911. I had a Kimber and it was a jam-o-matic.

You are dismissing the ENTIRE design, one of the most popular, proven and long-lived handguns extant, because ONE gun from ONE manufacturer "was a jam-o-matic?"

Ooooookaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay.

My 625 PC was defective as shipped. Doesn't mean I won't ever own another revolver.

Have fun with the 610. Properly built, it is a fun gun.

 

[Amici]

If you have your chambers lengthened, you will also be able to shoot 10MM Magnum from that model 610.

The 610 is DESIGNED to shoot 10mm.

As in, "out of the box" - no lengthening needed. This was noted in at least one earlier post in this thread.

http://www.smith-wesson.com/wcsstore/SmWesson/upload/other/ProductPR/Model 610.pdf

 

[jcelect]

6 vs 14

If you can't get the job done in 6 rounds, 8 more ain't gonna help a lick! I shoot the 610 in bowling pins matches every week! It dones a fine job with less recoil than the 41 or 44 Mag.
jcelect SWCA#723

 

[Hound]

The 610 is DESIGNED to shoot 10mm.

As in, "out of the box" - no lengthening needed. This was noted in at least one earlier post in this thread.

http://www.smith-wesson.com/wcsstore/SmWesson/upload/other/ProductPR/Model 610.pdf

You missed the part where he said "10mm Magnum". That is a different creature from the 10mm Auto that you're telling him the 610 was designed for. Google up some pics of the 10mm Magnum and you'll notice a fairly significant difference in cartridge length.

 

[Amici]

You missed the part where he said "10mm Magnum". That is a different creature from the 10mm Auto that you're telling him the 610 was designed for. Google up some pics of the 10mm Magnum and you'll notice a fairly significant difference in cartridge length.

You're right; I went right by the "magnum." I looked at the accompanying photo and saw "10 MM" clearly stated thereon and wondered what he missed. It was me.

Haven't seen any MAGNUMs around me, although the 610 is highly desirable. The 625 being far more plentiful, those are what most people get instead.

 

[AKAOV1MAN]

I have 2 610s, a 4" and a 3". They are a hoot to shoot. You can get some botique 10mm ammo that is really hot, puts out a 220 gr super hard cast slug at 1450 FPS. It might be the only auto load I might trust for large animal defense. Still working on it, kind of a labor of love......
Shooting the 610 with 40s is like shooting a really hot 32. The big gun just soaks up recoil so that even the 180 gr load is fun to shoot. I would not feel undergunned with a 610 loaded with either round. BTW with a little practice it is lightening fast to reload.

 

[pinkymingeo]

I had a cylinder reamed to 10mm Magnum, and did a fair bit of experimenting with it. Starline makes the brass. Never could get significantly better performance than regular 10mm, but I was probably too conservative with my loads. Finally sold it to a forum member. Don't know where it is now. As pointed out, 610's have a lot of weight due to thick cylinder and barrel walls, and absorb recoil very well. Not so hot for CCW, but great for shooting.