686P 4" Holster Challenge - Amazon.com

[CamoLaw]

I just purchased a 686P 4" and plan on carrying it frequently. I've been researching holsters for quite a while and for most usage, I think I will be going with the Bianchi X-15 (hiking, driving, etc.).

However, I want a non-shoulder holster to carry it concealed too. To make things a little more interesting, and narrowly focused, I have the following conditions:

1) I am limiting myself to a $75 gift card to Amazon.com (give or take $10 or so) that I won in an office pool.
2) I do not want an IWB holster.
3) It must be brown leather.
4) Must be fairly concealable (especially with suits and sport coats).

Any suggestions? Thanks!

 

[alwaysoutdoors]

Good luck with carrying that brick!

 

[Smith357]

I too am searching for a holster for a 4" L frame, mine is a 586. I have bought a few cheap holsters to test out which method I like best for such a large firearm, so far I'm leaning towards a Threeperson's style, It conceals pretty well under coat or heavy shirt and is very comfortable as an all day rig, but I have yet to try a pancake. When I do finally make my choice I will contract a custom maker to do the work.

Here are a few to get you started.

Desantis
Amazon.com: DeSantis Right Hand - Tan - Speed Scabbard (2 Slot) 002TA34Z0: Sports & Outdoors

Bianchi
Amazon.com: Bianchi - 5BH Leather Holster: Sports & Outdoors

Galco
Amazon.com: Galco Silhouette High Ride Holster for S&W L FR 686 4-Inch: Sports & Outdoors

 

[blujax01]

Challenge Accepted

Gould and Goodrich 803-94. Under $50. Pay no attention to the gun in the picture. Optics Planet stock photo used for all models whether revolver or auto.
Check the model 803-94 with the Gould web site. It is the correct part for the 686.
Amazon.com: Gould & Goodrich 803-94 Three Slot Pancake Holster, Chestnut: Sports & Outdoors

 

[Broker50]

I can reccomend Desantis #2 Speed Scabbard. Available at several online retailers for about $50.00, comes in brown or black, also availabe (#1) with a thumbreak, not necessary IMO. Carries that gun reall y well. Make no mistake, that's a big, heavy gun, takes dedication to carry one that big & heavy. Don't believe you will like the X15, bet that's the start of your unused holster box that we all have!

 

[CamoLaw]

Haha. Thanks for the input everyone. This is by far one of the best forums I've ever been on.

I really like the G&G linked above and will likely go that route. Either way, I'll update this thread with what I decide and how it works.

Once again, thanks everyone!

Before I forget, and at those prices... anyone have a similar suggestion for a good belt?

 

[Broker50]

Don Hume, 1 1/2" double thickness, available several places online, about $40.00

 

[Smith357]

The Amish make some fine leather products, they are masters at horse leather.
CCW Belt - Amish Work Belts - Free Shipping

Personal Care | Accessories and Clothing | Amish-Made Leather Belts - Lehmans.com

 

[Broker50]

Here ya' go, another option.

b109L - Don Hume Lined Trouser Holster Belt - Concealment Holsters & Gear - Red Diamond Uniform & Police Supply, Inc. - Detail

 

[CamoLaw]

I decided to go with the DeSantis Speed Scabbard in black. Although I originally requested opinions on a brown holster, the holsters I liked were too tan for my tastes. Also, I assume a black holster may be a little easier to conceal and not show up as easily in the "gaps" when I'm wearing dark suits for work. I talked to a few more people who highly recommended DeSantis holsters and decided to go with them.

Thanks everyone!

 

[Bordertown Devil]

I was going to recommend a Galco DAO. Got one for my 625 Mountain Gun in 45 acp and I LOVE LOVE LOVE it! Got it on Amazon for around $71 if memory serves.

 

[mowgli284]

I have a don humes 721-7 for a 586 for sale that has had the gun in it a couple of times, but never carried it. Sorry for the huge pic, can't figure out how to resize it.

p://[/IMG]

If anyone is interested make an offer, cash, ammo.