9mm Shield Trigger a bit heavy

Troman50

Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2014
Messages
11
Reaction score
1
Location
Oregon
I just purchased a 9mm Shield, and the trigger is bit heavy. This week I plan to take it a local GS to have him measure the pull wgt.

So my question is if it does, in fact, measure above the advertised 6.5 lbs. by a significant amount (not quite sure what would be considered "significant"), will S&W repair it under warranty? I have not even fired the gun yet...just dry fired with snap caps a couple hundred times.

And will the trigger lighten up a bit with use? What is a reasonable expectation for the trigger pull......

Thanks for any advice.
 
Register to hide this ad
It gets better! Needs to break in some. Mine was the same way, and after roughly 3-500 ends down range it started feeling much better. Now Im close to 1000 rnds down range and it feels pretty good. Its a little gritty out of the box. Give it some time to break in and see how it feels. I think you will end up loving it. I know I do.
 
Thanks so much for the headsup regarding being patient and allowing some time to "heal" the trigger!
 
Dry fire the **** out of it. I am doing that to mine and it has improved ALOT. I also cleaned it a few times and used Slip 2000 EWL and the grittiness is gone. Sit in front of the TV and dryfire it as much as you can.
 
Last edited:
Dry fire the **** out of it. I am doing that to mine and it has improved ALOT. I also cleaned it a few times and used Slip 2000 EWL and the grittiness is gone. Sit in front of the TV and dryfire it as much as you can.

For those who have never used a really good trigger--smooth, proper length of pull, and a sear break that is safe but not too heavy--any trigger that makes a gun go bang will do. I don't understand continuing to shoot a substandard trigger hoping it will slowly improve.

One of the best $50 accessories I ever bought was a Lyman digital trigger pull gauge. It has helped me fix many, many triggers and paid for itself many times over.

I understand dry firing is a fairly cheap, labor intensive way to eventually help smooth a poor trigger. It may reduce the pull weight a little, but usually not very much. It is certainly better than wasting hundreds of dollars worth of ammo to get an almost acceptable trigger pull.

I believe a trigger should be as you want it (at least what the factory claims) right away and that you should practice with it that way, not in a decreasingly less sucky configuration. This is a tool, a machine. It can be adjusted and fixed to meet your needs.

Following You Tube videos for disassembly and polishing component parts is more satisfying and will yield much faster and better results than a bunch of dry or live firing hoping to improve a trigger. I polished my Shield trigger components and it smoothed out, but the pull weight was still above 7.5 lbs.

I broke down and ordered an Apex Shield Carry Kit (SCK) and installed it. Not really difficult. Now I have a smooth 5.5# pull weight and other distinct advantages over the shipped factory setup. Worth it, but it certainly makes your investment in the gun go up.

You will find your Shield trigger pull, if it is like mine was, is probably 8.5 lbs or more. That's ridiculous on a small gun. It makes it very hard to shoot well--either accurately or fast, both of which are desirable for personal defense. BTW 8.5 lbs is 2 lbs over the marketing claim of 6.5 lbs, or a whopping 30% heavier than what they claim. If this is a machine you intend to use to save lives, the critical trigger component should be the best it can possibly be. S&W sets their claim at 6.5# as an average, I understand, but it is an average that has a lawyer's margin of error (extra weight) for "safety".

Once the trigger job is done, you can (and should) dry fire a lot, and practice with live ammo too. You will have better results and be more satisfied with your Shield with an improved trigger.
 
Boy, I have watched that Apex Shield Carry Kit (SCK) installation video 2 times now and it looks real appealing. They also don't look that unreasonable of a install. I modded all my Glocks ALOT to smooth them out. I vowed I wouldn't do it again but I don't know about the Apex Carry Kit. It looks like a quality mod.
 
For those who have never used a really good trigger--smooth, proper length of pull, and a sear break that is safe but not too heavy--any trigger that makes a gun go bang will do. I don't understand continuing to shoot a substandard trigger hoping it will slowly improve.

One of the best $50 accessories I ever bought was a Lyman digital trigger pull gauge. It has helped me fix many, many triggers and paid for itself many times over.

I understand dry firing is a fairly cheap, labor intensive way to eventually help smooth a poor trigger. It may reduce the pull weight a little, but usually not very much. It is certainly better than wasting hundreds of dollars worth of ammo to get an almost acceptable trigger pull.

I believe a trigger should be as you want it (at least what the factory claims) right away and that you should practice with it that way, not in a decreasingly less sucky configuration. This is a tool, a machine. It can be adjusted and fixed to meet your needs.

Following You Tube videos for disassembly and polishing component parts is more satisfying and will yield much faster and better results than a bunch of dry or live firing hoping to improve a trigger. I polished my Shield trigger components and it smoothed out, but the pull weight was still above 7.5 lbs.

I broke down and ordered an Apex Shield Carry Kit (SCK) and installed it. Not really difficult. Now I have a smooth 5.5# pull weight and other distinct advantages over the shipped factory setup. Worth it, but it certainly makes your investment in the gun go up.

You will find your Shield trigger pull, if it is like mine was, is probably 8.5 lbs or more. That's ridiculous on a small gun. It makes it very hard to shoot well--either accurately or fast, both of which are desirable for personal defense. BTW 8.5 lbs is 2 lbs over the marketing claim of 6.5 lbs, or a whopping 30% heavier than what they claim. If this is a machine you intend to use to save lives, the critical trigger component should be the best it can possibly be. S&W sets their claim at 6.5# as an average, I understand, but it is an average that has a lawyer's margin of error (extra weight) for "safety".

Once the trigger job is done, you can (and should) dry fire a lot, and practice with live ammo too. You will have better results and be more satisfied with your Shield with an improved trigger.


I tend to avoid doing trigger modifications outside of the factory setup for a carry gun, and this is why I'd rather have S&W pony up and repair the trigger pull to meet its advertised pull wgt.

As I said, I'll get the pull measured by the local GS and then, if necessary, call S&W Customer Service to warranty the repair.

S&W CS has always taken care of any issues that I have had and this goes back to 1975.......however, the only real "issues" I have had with my Smiths have been with recently manufactured revolvers (.....the revolvers all function perfectly now, but I have had to call upon the factory to utilize their gunsmiths to fix them. And in each instance, they handled the repair request with friendliness and a willingness to make things right)

So I'll rely on S&W to fix this issue as well.

I certainly appreciate your perspective and agree that quality should be expected!
 
Just got 2 9mm Shields
Fired 50 rounds thru each

My trigger pull 7.10
My sons 8.01

Seems a little heavy
may need to send them back. I am waiting hear from S&W about the Brass bulge we see in both guns
 
Boy, I have watched that Apex Shield Carry Kit (SCK) installation video 2 times now and it looks real appealing. They also don't look that unreasonable of a install. I modded all my Glocks ALOT to smooth them out. I vowed I wouldn't do it again but I don't know about the Apex Carry Kit. It looks like a quality mod.

Personally, I've done both M&P and Glock trigger mods with drop in parts. IMO, the Apex sear in an M&P produces a crisper trigger than the Glock mods. For a carry gun, I'd recommend the duty kit from Apex. The S&W factory trigger return spring tends to make the triggers a bit to light ( in a carry gun) with their sear. I use the heavier MA spring and the apex sear to get just over 5#.
I wouldn't bother with the plunger replacement. That can be a job (removing the rear sight) and adds little for a carry gun.
 
I didn't wait for break in since this is my carry pistol. I put in new sights along with the apex carry kit and apex trigger. I measure with my pull gage and get 5 and 3/4 lb pull.
 
I have a MA compliant trigger. Is the only thing required to bring the trigger back to the standard OEM 6 lbs, a simple change of the trigger return spring?
 
Last edited:
Give it time! I have both MP45 and MP9. Both are great. Bit heavy, but nice clean crisp break. Hey they are combat guns! I can shoot both of mine with a great degree of accuracy!

Remember too, SW like all gun makers are mass producing these products. As well as liability in our wonderful Lawsuit Happy society!
 
I am primarily a Glock guy, but the Shield fits my summer carry needs better. It takes a little getting used to, but having the internals polished really smooths it out. It doesn't make it lighter, but it feels a little lighter due to the smooth pull and clean break. And...shokt the **** out of it. After about 600 rounds it will settle in nicely.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top