Are Prices on Used S&Ws Dropping?

Status
Not open for further replies.

daa9mm

Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2008
Messages
222
Reaction score
2
I've been buying used S&W revolvers for a little over a year now. I've seen prices go up tremendously in that time and now they seem to be dropping in price because they are not selling in gun shops around my area.
Are they dropping because the election panic is over or because there is less money available to buy them?
Or a combination of both?
Thanks
 
Register to hide this ad
I've been buying used S&W revolvers for a little over a year now. I've seen prices go up tremendously in that time and now they seem to be dropping in price because they are not selling in gun shops around my area.
Are they dropping because the election panic is over or because there is less money available to buy them?
Or a combination of both?
Thanks
 
I have only seen them go up in the past couple of years. where are you located? I may have to take a shopping trip?
icon_smile.gif
 
The S&Ws I've been tracking have all increased in price. Some more or less keeping pace with inflation, others appreciating faster than inflation, like the 547s, 686 2-1/2" Bbl, 686 Mountain Gun, 617 4" Bbl.
 
I think those that have them for sale, are holding on to the bitter end on their prices. I have noticed and commented to my wife several times lately, that here on the forum, I have seen several 28-2's in the past few weeks for sale for quite a while. Back at Christmas time and on up to the election, they would have sold almost immediately. Now they are sitting on the forum and the owners are even lowering their prices.

It's just my observation, but I watch the forum prices pretty closely, as well as a several off forum sites.
 
Everyone is spending all their money of black rifles and ammo right now. The S&W market, where I am, has slowed a bit but prices haven't changed that much.
 
In the area where I live S&W's seem to bring a premium and are scarce on the used market, That is something nice. I looked for some time for a used model 13 well I found one that was tight, timing in, though the finish about 90% due to not seeing many I went with it 300.00 +
Its a smith!!! the days of a 175.00 police trade in seem long gone.
Carl
 
In my area any thing smith other than the Model 10's seem to be holding their value or going up, they are selling so fast that the dealer I frequent has quit putting them on the website, they are gone before he can get them there. The model 10's are pretty low priced but I think that is because that dealer just bought about 100 of them that look pretty rough with holster wear so he has them priced to move.

Around here the real bargains right now are in shotguns, it seems everyone is trading their shotguns in for handguns and assaults. That same dealer has 3 extra aisle of used shotguns, that is a 300% increase in used shotguns since he normally has 1 aisle and he now has 4.
 
Everyone is spending all their money of black rifles and ammo right now. The S&W market, where I am, has slowed a bit but prices haven't changed that much.

This is what I see here in NC Indiana. There is also a lot of money being spent on components. Prices on most S&Ws are as high as ever, but without a lot of activity. The would-be sellers aren't budging just yet. The models that are not in such high demand (i.e., anything that I am NOT interested in
icon_wink.gif
) seem to be starting to creep back just a bit, but you still see screwy prices on old junker Model 10s. This is nothing new. It is just that the screwy prices on the old junker Model 10s are higher than they used to be. This type of seller disconnect never goes away.
 
We've never really defined the proper terms here, but one that applies are "collector grade" or "Investment grade". To me they seem a bit different. With significantly more rarity attached to the investment guns.

But what I'm trying to get to is the idea that the cream of the corp guns have skyrocketed in price. They don't just remain there, they are accelerating upward. The collector grade guns, the ones in great condition, often described as "As new in box", still command the same lofty prices. Then we have the prewar guns which took a huge leap a while back. Those, even the common guns in nice shape aren't easy to locate, and when you do, you throw down a bundle.

Just which S&Ws are going down in price? Maybe the red headed stepchild? Those always used to be the Victory models, followed by the M10s no one wanted. Seen any in good shape for less than $400 recently? I remember when street sales here in KY were thick with corroded ones or cut down barrel guns for under $100. We're not talking 20 years ago, we're talking 10 years ago.

Hint: M&Ps are doing better than your 401k, and surely better than your bank stocks, automotive stocks, not to mention Enron, Worldcomm, or the other, formerly great investments, Fanny and Freddie. Sorry if you owned any of those star performers. An as new in box prewar k22 has some appeal.
 
In my little part of the world, they are going up. I don't see any decline in prices at all.
 
Whether prices have peaked or not, they will peak and then, decline. There has been obvious panic buying after the election. But, that type of surge in demand will end eventually. And, like every other bubble, the bubble for guns will pop, probably when we least expect it to.

What will bring the prices down? Three things: (1) oversupply, as manufacturers gear up their production and distribution to meet anticipated demand; (2) a dropoff in demand as customers buy what they want/need and cease buying; (3) prices that exceed what customers are willing to pay. On that last point the poor performance of the economony generally will inevitably affect what people can afford to buy.

My last point is purely anecdotal. I've noticed recently, that on Gunbroker, sellers are demanding astronomical prices for what they're offering. But, I've also noticed that very little (aside from the no reserve guns) is selling. That suggests to me that the market for guns -- sort of like the market for houses a couple of years ago -- is overdue for a correction. I've also noticed that my local gun store, which carries guns on consignment, has had several sitting in their display cases for weeks now that I expect would have sold quickly had the sellers been more reasonable in terms of what they're demanding.

Personally, I'm holding off making any purchases 'til summer. My guess is that, by then, the market will have cooled considerably.
 
I would guess that the market for sales will at least hold steady until everyone sees just what type of legislation the annointed one passes.
 
I've seen the same revolvers sitting in the used gun displays now for several weeks. They have marked prices down some, but not much. When asked for their best price, they don't negotiate. One dealer told me he didn't have many used guns in inventory and wanted to hang onto them. I told him he would at the price he had them marked.
I do believe they will come down as the sale of the older used revolvers seems to have slowed considerably in central Oklahoma.
 
Right now anything "tactical" seems to be all the rage. ARs, Glocks, "riot" shotguns, that sort of thing. I don't see as many revolvers being sold right now, although finding the J-frame 38/357s is currently a bit tricky. I reckon they fall into the "tactical" category somewhat.

We don't have a lot of used S&Ws show up around here, just when there's a gun-show in town.....and we only get maybe three or four of those a year. I think one is coming later this month and I'm in the mood to buy something, think I'll look around and see if there are any bargains, although you rarely find those at gun-shows I've noticed.
 
I'll tell ya what I've noted lately in S.C.,prices seem to be rising on everything!Gun shows?Forget about it.About the only thing I've got any deal at all on is reload ammo at the gun show,$12.50 for 45acp,$11.50 for 38spcl,50 rnd bags.Not bad! I got 300 rnds that day,wish I had more $ to blow! Jim
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top