Are these worth the asking price?

Edge

Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
21
Reaction score
0
Have the opportunity to purchase these old Smiths and was wondering if any of you think they are worth it or if they are asking too much....

S&W 32-20 $600
S/N 426XX
6-1/2" barrel; grips have diamonds, but no S&W medalion

S&W 1950 45 cal. $1900
S/N S932XX

S&W K-22 $750
S/N K865XX
6" barrel; white grips, fake ivory

S&W K-22 Outdoorsman $1850
S/N 661XXX
6" barrel; beautiful shape

S&W K-22 $600
S/N K689XX
6" barrel; holster wear, etc.
 
Register to hide this ad
All the prices except the K-22s appear crazy high to me.
If the K-22s are very nice, the price may be ok.
I will defer to others, but I buy too many Smiths to see those prices as
fair.
 
A lot depends on condition. To be anywhere near the prices listed they would all have to be unfired NIB with all papers & tools, and then some are still Very Very high.
 
Even at 98% (and I don't know their condition), the .32-20, .45 and Outdoorsman would be overpriced. If they do not grade that high, they are WAY overpriced.

The more expensive K-22 might be worth the price if it is at least a 97-98% gun. I doubt the last K-22, with "holster wear" could rate that percentage, but it might be worth $600 if it is a 95% gun.

There are probably some subjective factors to bear in mind that would only come to the fore if there was a chance for a detailed inspection.
 
Thanks for the input! I thought that they were overpriced and usually this guy is on the high side. I doubt that I'll be able to talk him down at all either, so I'm sure they'll sit there for a long time.
 
The seller is not even close. I don't care if S & W delivers them from their secret store house of NIB oldies.

This is the kind of greed that keeps me home on gun show day.
 
The seller is not even close. I don't care if S & W delivers them from their secret store house of NIB oldies.

This is the kind of greed that keeps me home on gun show day.

It can't be stated any better than that !!!!

Keep looking.

Steve
 
Wow . . . sounds like you weren't in a gun shop at all, but a "museum." Didn't know there were many "museums" left anymore!!!

Let me explain . . .

Years ago (well before the internet and forums) there were several old mom and pop gun stores in the deep South that I'd frequent . . . just to see lots of cool, vintage era handguns.

Each store had 'em priced at breathtakingly high prices like the ones you posted here. I called those stores "museums," for they only sold enough stuff to keep their doors open.

Alas, these shops I frequented are all gone now . . . and their stocks all sold off at auction. Heck, the owners are all passed away now too.

Their greed kept 'em both poor AND working into their '80s just to pay the rent, and in the end . . . they couldn't take the guns with 'em either.

I don't see many "museums" anymore. Then again . . . I don't see many gun shops at all anymore. It is a tough business without much profit for the time and effort.

BTW, here's my latest catch . . . bought from the collection of a guy who USED to run a "museum" in my town. I only was able to part him from one rifle back when he was alive and in business . . . the other stuff I wanted he'd never come off of.

Alas, after he died his heirs decided to sell off all the guns he'd hoarded . . . as a group . . . and another fella who'd opened a pawn shop here bought the whole collection . . . probably for a price that would have had ol' Joe spinning in his grave.

Anyhow . . . here's my new (to me) post-war M&P. Kinda purdy if I say so myself. At least this one will be appreciated and cared for.

2454099IMG2078p-pi-c.jpg
 
Yep . . . at one of the former "museums" in my area, around 1997, the old man still had a new old stock 6" barreled 27-2 with all the goodies.

He always wanted way too much for it so I gave up on it and looked for one elsewhere. Finally one day in '98 I asked about it again, but just in a casual way and he said, "Five Fifty." I guess he needed the money at the time . . . so I bought it.

Now back then $550 was about the going rate I was seeing for really nice ones . . . and this one was as new as a new, twenty-year old gun could be. A year or so later I heard the place had an auction in it and that he'd closed up shop forever.
 
I love Gunbroker and the Blue Book of dreams and can only guess that somebody has been smoking that beef jerky from the gun show.

I went into a store in Tarpon Springs Florida owned by your sellers brother. They had insane prices and I actually started laughing a few times as they explained how they conjured the crazy prices. He had an M1A NIB for $4000 bucks, it was "preban". Not like the new new ones. I think you can do better.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top