best bullet for practicing competition shooting

Joined
Oct 21, 2013
Messages
16
Reaction score
2
Location
Southern Pines, NC
hey all, quick question. this is my first time reloading and wanted to know what everyone is using bullet wise. i plan on buying from xtreme bullets and am looking for .40S&W. just not sure on if i should get 165 RNFP, 165 RNFP HPCB, 180 RNFP, or 180 RNFP HPCB...

ill be shooting a S&W M&P .40 full size.

any help would be great. thanks
 
Register to hide this ad
What style competition?

I would think the load and bullet should attempt to duplicate the load and bullet you'll use in competition.

Or use the handloads in competition.

I like heavy, plated bullets from XTreme. My 38s are 158gr flattened nose round point.


Sgt Lumpy
 
competitions similar to USPSA, IDPA SCSA and the like... plus just for simple target practice... im new to the competition world and reloading but not new to shooting guns. every time that i have shot to qualify for any job or schooling the .40 S&W 180 FMJ was used so naturally thats what i figured i should go with but wasnt completely sure
 
I shoot (and load) exactly the same ammo that I shoot in a match. Doing anything else doesn't make a lot of sense to me.
 
I use .40 cal. 180 gr. plated round nose Xtreme bullets for practice and competition. The reason I shoot 180 gr. bullets, I need to make USPSA major power factor (165), (bullet weight X velocity divided by 1000 = power factor). I've found that I'd rather manage recoil with a slightly heavier bullet, lower velocity cartridge rather than a lighter faster bullet, with higher velocity. If you are shooting a M&P .40 in USPSA you may shoot open, limited, limited 10 or production division. Of course you are at major disadvantage in open and limited division. Production division has a minor only power factor of (125). Therefore achieving a 125 PF with a .40 cartridge is going to be expensive and unnecessary. Also may compromise your guns reliability unless your power factor is considerably higher than 125(155+). Not to mention competitive shooters in production division all shoot 9mm. Recoil, cartridge cost and recoil management are all significantly lower with the 9mm. My recommendation would be to use 180 gr. bullets with the .40 cal. cartridge. The velocity needed to make major PF is 917 ft./sec with a 180 gr. bullet. There's a lot of powder available to give you a very manageable recoil from this bullet weight. I use Xtreme 180 gr. RNFP.
 
Last edited:
thank you very much colt22man. very helpful! if you woudlnt mind sharing what powder and primer do you use? also i assume the brass i use isnt a huge factor as long as its clean and doesnt have any bulges?
 
"BEST" BULLET FOR COMPETITION

I'm new to competition shooting, not shooting or reloading. I am burning up a lot more ammo now and get better groups/times with powderpuff loads, as well as saving money using less powder and cast bullets. I still need 1 more mag to compete with my 40 cal, a Sig 239, which gets the best accuracy with a 155 gr hornady xtp & 6 gr's unique. I couldn't afford to practice & compete with xtp's, nor put the extra wear & tear on the gun with a load that warm. I'm not telling you what load to use! Just start low and work up until you find a sweet spot for your gun/pocketbook/recoil tolerance.
 
My range load of 5.4 grains of IMR SR7625 will produce 960 fps from my Sig P229. I may be observing something that isn't really there but I believe that this particular load has less perceived recoil and muzzle flip than the 180 grain Federal Champion which clocks in at 950 fps. As for why I may be seeing something that isn't really happening, it is a very very clean shooting load with barely any observed muzzle flash. In addition SR7625 meters perfectly in my powder measures. If you really want to go soft a 5.2 grain load of the same powder should produce 920 fps and it's distinctly soft shooting with enough energy to reliably cycle my P229.
 
Back
Top