I have got to get me one of those spoons!
Seriously though, I want very hard to believe, but common sense rears it's ugly head. I follow reported sightings through the various websites, and can usually whittle out what I believe is credible from the wierd. For instance, one persons idea of "Deep Woods" dosen't hold up to anothers. Someone who is not used to being outdoors will look at a patch of woods @30 acres and think they're in the deep wilderness. To someone willing to take the time, a squirrel couldn't move around it with out being observed. I also like all the photos shot intentionally out of focus or without something for comparison. While there are credible photos and videos out there, all the hoaxs tear down their credibility.
It is a joke with my wife that when ever she finds me being "unproductive", my response is that I'm hunting Bigfoot.