So, when you eat 'em are they wet, or damp? You say cook 'em 'til they're tender. Do you shell 'em first, before cooking? Sounds like you don't wait for 'em to dry out.
I guess they are not crunchy like your typical salted peanut right after you pop the lid on a fresh jar or can of 'em.
I'd like to try 'em if get a chance someday.
Try them, you'll like 'em!

But, don't ever make the mistake of buying a can of boiled peanuts in the store. They are terrible.
You cook them in the shell. Around me, there is a guy (The Peanut Guy) that sells them in the local bowling alley parking lot on Saturday's. He has 3 different sizes, a medium sized styrofoam cup, a large styrofoam cup, or an extra large bucket. He pulls them straight from the hot water, drains them, and puts them in what ever sized container you want. Eat your fill and refrigerate the rest. After reading this thread, I got a hankering for some "berreled p-nuts", so I googled his site. Here it is:
https://www.peanutguy.com/
I noticed he is not open because he couldn't get the peanuts he prefers. Hopefully, this is from last year! BTW, the 2 extremely cute little girls, the owner's granddaughters, I believe, are the best salespeople you have ever seen!! I have always associated boiled peanuts with college football. Back in the day, while a student at Clemson, we would go to a local bar to watch football on TV, and order a pitcher and a bag. You would get a pitcher of beer, a quart plastic bag of boiled peanuts, and a kinda flat cardboard box (the kind that a case of beer cans used to come in) to put your empty shells in. The local high school, about 20 years ago, used to sell "shelled" boiled peanuts in a styrofoam cup at the concession stand. I never tried them, but I guess they boiled the shelled peanuts.

Larry