Bowie!

RonJ

US Veteran
Joined
Mar 31, 2006
Messages
3,939
Reaction score
2,574
Location
Missouri
I am interested in buying a good quality Bowie. I know that the top makers charge astronomical prices that I can't afford.
May I get some recommendations for a decent knife for under $200.00? Thanks in advance.......
 
Register to hide this ad
I've got one of the older Westerns, it has great steel and will hold an edge like no tomorrow. Were I in the market these days I'd take a close look at Cold Steel.
 
I'm going to have to politely disagree with 5BeansintheWheel. Granted, there are some beautiful, high-quality, handmade Bowies out there that are well worth the price. But, you can still find a good, well-made "usin' knife" out there for under $200.

Case in point...Cold Steel's Laredo Bowie, which normally sells for $284.99, can be purchased through Amazon for $156.10. It's got a 10½-inch blade that is 5/16 of an inch thick and made out of SK-5 high carbon steel. And it comes razor sharp. While the top of the tip doesn't come sharpened, it doesn't take much to put a good edge on that, too.

Okay, it's not made in the USA, but to find a knife of that quality that is made in the US for under two hundred bucks is kinda like having a champagne taste on a beer budget.
LaredoBowie001_zps91e814a7.jpg
 
Last edited:
Texas Star will be along on a minute..:D
Thanks. I'll probably be of only modest help.

The best bargain in a good knife of this sort may be Buck's Models 119 and 120. The clip point isn't honed, so unless the blade is just too long in your jurisdiction, it should be legal. (Either model. The 120 is just a longer form of the 119. Blades are about 6 and 7.25 inches.) I have and love both.

The Cold Steel Trailmaster mentioned may be under your price point, or close.

How long a Bowie? The Fallkniven A-1 is basically an Improved Bowie shape, the blade a bit over six inches. If you get the pure A-1, it'll have a Kraton or Thermorun handle. For more money, you can find the same basic blade in their Northern Lights (NL) series. The A-1 probably averages between $150-200 from US dealers. Prices on the site are in Swedish kroner/crowns. The NL version may reach (guess) $250. But shop several US dealers, or query the site for names of US dealers. I think they'll sell directly, but probably prefer to steer you to importers or dealers. That will also avoid currency issues. Work all the buttons on their site. You'll be impressed! www.fallkniven.com Especially check the survival/miitary and sheath knife buttons. Model S-1 is a top outdoors knife, a smaller version of the A-1 I've posted here frequently about these knives and am short of time now. Read their site. If you want a longer, heavier knife, see models NL-1 and NL-2. Unless you really feel the need for a long blade, stop at the NL-2. The blade is about 20CM, almost 8 inches. It's well balanced, so feels lighter than it is. It's a good chopper if you need to make a shelter in the woods. Handle is leather with
colored fiber trim, with stainless guard and alloy butt cap. Yes, the handle may remind you of Randall.

Why do you want the knife? If your goal is wearing it to Old West events, you'll prefer the classic look. I haven't seen the Chinese-made Han-Wei knives other than in photos, but member Theur has a few and likes the brand. He's trying to encourage the maker to provide some gambler's dirks and push daggers, too, having met them recently at the IWA show in Nuremburg. (Theur is Dutch.) Ask him for more on Han-Wei. If he likes them, they probably are worthwhile.

But his interest seems to be mainly in wearing them to Old West meets. I don't know if he hunts, hikes, or camps. Does anyone here really use Han-Wei knives?
 
Last edited:
$284.99 $156.10 SK-5
I'm going to have to politely disagree with 5BeansintheWheel. Granted, there are some beautiful, high-quality, handmade Bowies out there that are well worth the price. But, you can still find a good, well-made "usin' knife" out there for under $200.

Case in point...Cold Steel's Laredo Bowie, which normally sells for $284.99, can be purchased through Amazon for $156.10. It's got a 10½-inch blade that is 5/16 of an inch thick and made out of SK-5 high carbon steel. Okay, it's not made in the USA, but to find a knife of that quality that is made in the US for under two hundred bucks is kinda like having a champagne taste on a beer budget.
LaredoBowie001_zps91e814a7.jpg

The fact that is not one the earlier USA made rules it out for me. Nor am I fond of the cable with a nut for part of the tang they used on some knives. Sorry, with out researching the cable and nut, I am not sure which models used them. They have been known to break.

I won't even get involved in the carbon v and sk-5 debate.

Spend the extra $100 and get a USA made knife!!


Patrick
 
Hey Ron, here is a John Wayne Commemorative Bowie. I dont know how much these are, but id like one myself. I saw an Army Commemorative Bowie at the last gun show. The guy was asking $400.00.
fm_bowie-1.jpg

icon_e_surprised.gif
icon_e_surprised.gif
icon_e_surprised.gif
 
Patrick, I am unfortunately tied to the price.
To clarify, I want a genuine Jim Bowie style knife. Mostly to be used as a prop and a wall hanger. However I don't want one of those $29.95 super cheapies. I'd like to take a little bit of pride in ownership. Hell, I used to be proud of my old 64 Corvair! :)

Putting out the fire with gasoline!! My favorite Bowie song.
 
Last edited:
Ringo, that is a beauty and like the style I want. If I ever have a genuine desire to stick a pig maybe I'll save up.:D
 
Patrick, I am unfortunately tied to the price.
To clarify, I want a genuine Jim Bowie style knife. Mostly to be used as a prop and a wall hanger. However I don't want one of those $29.95 super cheapies. I'd like to take a little bit of pride in ownership. Hell, I used to be proud of my old 64 Corvair! :)

Putting out the fire with gasoline!! My favorite Bowie song.


It is believed that The knife used by Jim Bowie in the sand bar fight was a butcher knife.

How about a Case for a wall hanger?

Case XX Bowie Knife Black Handle - Case Bowie Knives


Or a Bear and Sons? I guess as wall hangers they would be okay. I don't know where their damascus comes from. But then again I have Sambar stag on 3 of mine.


http://www.discountcutlery.net/American-made-Bowie-Knives_c_3435.html

Patrick
 
Last edited:
Ringo, that is a beauty and like the style I want. If I ever have a genuine desire to stick a pig maybe I'll save up.:D

If you want? ill keep my eyes peeled for the type pictured. Its the kind I want too. Oh and I forgot--there was a dealer at this last show who did great work making all kinds of knifes--including Bowies. He does great work and had I had more on me to spend? I would have bought one--and im not really interested in collecting blades-though I do have around 10 of all types-but no Bowies yet. Also, I THINK the highest price I saw on his Bowies--was around $150.00. Every or most of the blades I saw, were Damascus blades.

I THINK I might have his contact info? Ill look if your interested?

Anyway, after I finally take the plunge for a Bowie--I want an Old Hickery knife.
 
Here are more images of the above:
fm_bowie-2.jpg

fm_bowie-3.jpg

bowie_advert.jpg

Just saw one sold on ebay for $333.00
 
Just saw another priced at $189.50. Its on a site called: collectionary.com

Id also love to have this comic book too.
lidenhcfo4naihufcw5b.jpg
 
I'm going to have to politely disagree with 5BeansintheWheel. Granted, there are some beautiful, high-quality, handmade Bowies out there that are well worth the price. But, you can still find a good, well-made "usin' knife" out there for under $200.

Case in point...Cold Steel's Laredo Bowie, which normally sells for $284.99, can be purchased through Amazon for $156.10. It's got a 10½-inch blade that is 5/16 of an inch thick and made out of SK-5 high carbon steel. And it comes razor sharp. While the top of the tip doesn't come sharpened, it doesn't take much to put a good edge on that, too.

Okay, it's not made in the USA, but to find a knife of that quality that is made in the US for under two hundred bucks is kinda like having a champagne taste on a beer budget.
LaredoBowie001_zps91e814a7.jpg



Wow! Who really makes that for them? Han-Wei, maybe?

Nice looking knife. Does it handle well?

I'm suspicious of Chinese steels and have never heard of the one mentioned.

Also, Lindermesser in Solingen makes some Bowie types as has Puma. You can probably find the 6.5-inch bladed Puma at a show. Depending on who has a good used one, you might be under $200.But the handle on that model of Puma is a bit short for MY hand. Mayne not yours.

The John Wayne knife made me laugh. Big, heavy, probably won't take and hold an edge well, and is likely very clumsy in the hand.
 
Last edited:
I just found this. It is the style I want and the price is great.
Any thoughts? I don't like the name plate on the handle though.

Amazon.com: Officially Licensed ALAMO MC-AB01 Hunting Knife 17.25-Inch Overall: Sports & Outdoors

That knife looks a lot like the one seen in several movies, like "The Last Command" and, "The Iron Maiden."

The shape of the clip point resembles that on a sword in a famous sculpture of Perseus.

Given the size and price, I'd avoid it for serious work, but for a wall hanger or display knife, it may be a good choice.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top