I wonder what it is that many of us find so attractive, so appealing, about flashlights that we keep on buying them when we already have more than we need?
They just have that nifty factor that is hard to resist....
(Like Muss and Rusty, the only one that I normally have with me is my phone, and that's normally all I use on the rare occasion I need one, but that doesn't keep me from continuing to buy them...)
What's the saying? "One is none, a dozen is one"...?
For me, I like having an independent light source. If necessary, I can use the light while talking on my phone. I can grab my light from my pocket and turn it on much quicker than pulling out my phone, unlocking it, and turning its light on. Plus I can turn a flashlight off and on quickly and easily if needed. I also don't have to worry about using up my phone's battery for the light when it may be only way to call for help in an emergency.
In a self defense situation, my flashlight is going to be brighter and more focused than my phone's light for disorienting an attacker. Plus, my flashlight makes for a better improvised impact tool than my phone. Not to mention that trying to use my phone as an impact tool could damage it, which would disable my ability to call 911.
I typically carry two flashlights. My keychain light is day-to-day, normal use. My larger, brighter one is used when I either need a brighter light source, if I need a less-lethal self defense tool in hand, or need to use it in conjunction with my gun to ID a threat.
So, to me, there are some very good practical reasons to have a separate flashlight from one's phone, particularly if someone is concerned with personal security. With lights getting smaller, brighter, and more efficient, excuses for not carrying one get weaker.
And one reason I have many lights is in large part due to advancing technology. When I did security work in the 90s I often carried a 5 D-cell Maglite. Then I went to the Surefire 6R, which I converted to 6P, as it was brighter in a smaller package. Then lights started getting thinner, smaller, and brighter, so I would try lights to take advantage of the new tech. My Nitecore MT1A is nearly half the size of my 6P, but 3x as bright. Not to mention it's always nice to have back-ups or lights for different roles. For example, my 6P is just too bulky to carry as an EDC light, but with a Malkoff warm-light flood lamp at 200 lumens, it makes for a good nightstand light.
Of course, the cool new toy factor figures in, as well. I'm certainly not immune to that.
