Went to the local gunshow today, I sold a couple of guns so had some cash to spend. I found a 3in 60-10 and also a 4 in 686-4. Neither of them had the box, but both were very nice, not perfect, but quite nice. The best price on the 60-10 was about $25 more than the 686-4. Back & forth, back & forth. Finally settled on the 686-4 as I didn't currently own a 686 but did have a 60-12. Of course I'm still second guessing myself, but still happy with my decision. Already had a pair of Hogue tulipwood combat grips to put on the 686-4 and they really set it off. Which do you think you would have gone for?