Florida Gun
Member
I have a Model 686 .357 Combat Magnum Revolver-Stainless in excellent condition.
Could any one tell me the approximate value of this gun?
Could any one tell me the approximate value of this gun?
Florida Gun
- Thread starter Florida Gun
- Start date
Register to hide this ad
7kings
Member
I just bought one in the 6" barrel for $700, but that was new.
Kernel Crittenden
US Veteran, Absent Comrade
At a minimum, need to know dash number and barrel length. A picture would be a BIG help. Product code is probably too much to ask for. Otherwise, $400 to $1,200.
OP
Florida Gun
Member
6" barrel Product Code 104223 Ser # AVE4687
Tell me how I find dash number and I will supply.
I have picture on my Iphone which I can send you if you want to give me your email address.
Tell me how I find dash number and I will supply.
I have picture on my Iphone which I can send you if you want to give me your email address.
Kernel Crittenden
US Veteran, Absent Comrade
What's the four digit number under "Spec. Ord."? Starts with a "6" or a "7".
You gun was made in 1986 - 1987. The special order number will help nail it down.
Your gun is a "dash one". Open the cylinder, look at the frame under the barrel, you should see a "Mod. 686-1" there. Above it the s/n. You may also see a "M" there. If not, your gun has not been sent back to S&W for a voluntary recall. Search "recall" for lots of info on that.
A 104223 is a plain standard production 6-inch M686. Forged parts. No lock. With the box, original wood Target Stocks, and in excellent condition, I'd put it in the $650 to $950 range. These fine guns come up all the time here and prices for older ones fluctuate widely around the country.
I'd find out what a brand new 6-inch M686-6 sells for in your area, then set that as the MINIMUM price you'd take. If it were mine, I'd wouldn't sell it for penny less than the new gun with the lock and MIM parts. Upper end is what you can get. Personally, I think they're worth more than the new guns.
You gun was made in 1986 - 1987. The special order number will help nail it down.
Your gun is a "dash one". Open the cylinder, look at the frame under the barrel, you should see a "Mod. 686-1" there. Above it the s/n. You may also see a "M" there. If not, your gun has not been sent back to S&W for a voluntary recall. Search "recall" for lots of info on that.
A 104223 is a plain standard production 6-inch M686. Forged parts. No lock. With the box, original wood Target Stocks, and in excellent condition, I'd put it in the $650 to $950 range. These fine guns come up all the time here and prices for older ones fluctuate widely around the country.
I'd find out what a brand new 6-inch M686-6 sells for in your area, then set that as the MINIMUM price you'd take. If it were mine, I'd wouldn't sell it for penny less than the new gun with the lock and MIM parts. Upper end is what you can get. Personally, I think they're worth more than the new guns.
Last edited:
OP
Florida Gun
Member
Spec Ord 7048 This is what appears under the cylinder--a slanted S over a 21 over 66992 No Mod 686-1 No M and nothing resembling the Serial Number
ptgarcia
Member
Look under the crane for the model number. This one below is a Model 586 (no dash) and the M is there indicating the recall repair was performed.
Last edited:
OP
Florida Gun
Member
Exactly where I looked and found what I just described to you. I find nothing on gun that shows Serial Number on box?
OP
Florida Gun
Member
Big mistake on my part Serial Number is there where you indicated--
Also M 686-1
Also M 686-1
OP
Florida Gun
Member
Those other numbers and letter S were on the part that mates up when u close the cylinder
Kid44
Member
Maybe it's just me because I'm having a really bad day, but why are you asking others to do something you can easily figure out for yourself. Look it up, google it, check websites where guns are sold, ask a stranger, I don't know, it's worth what someone is willing to give you for it.
Give him a break, he's new here.
OP
Florida Gun
Member
Kid44--I explored several of the options u mentioned and received estimates all over the board. I belong to a gun club with over 500 members-the handgun devotees also had varying opinions based on their desire to purchase at a bargain price. I figured I would try a S & W forum where I felt I might have a chance of getting a true answer from someone not interested in buying the gun.Seems like that is what Mr Crittenden was doing! That answer your question?
Kernel Crittenden
US Veteran, Absent Comrade
That's a S&W code for the ship date of.......
February 17, 1987.
You'll also find the s/n on the bottom of the grip frame. That's been S&W's primary s/n spot since forever. Your grips may be obscuring it.
Other than the s/n, model number, dash number, and in this case the "M"; all the other numbers, symbols, and stampings don't really mean anything to the collector. They're markings left over from the manufacturing process. (When you take the grips off you'll see a whole bunch more).
Asking and answering questions is one of the primary reasons for this forum's existence. It's a good practice to simply ignore post that are not of interest.
OP
Florida Gun
Member
Thanks for your reply! Normally, I would ignore a comment as seen above but...So, if you can give me an idea what to reasonably expect in the Central Florida area, I would appreciate your advice.
Kernel Crittenden
US Veteran, Absent Comrade
Already did. Twice.
Attention to detail is not your strong point, is it Florida Gun.
LittleCooner
Member
Crank up the chainsaw. Sometimes we can not see the forest for all the trees standing in the way and the best solution is to cut down the trees for a better view of the Forest.
Kernel - you did a super job of assisting this guy, its why I love the forum. Lot of info and a lot of people willing to share that information,
Kernel - you did a super job of assisting this guy, its why I love the forum. Lot of info and a lot of people willing to share that information,
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2007
- Messages
- 27,669
- Reaction score
- 21,359
Welcome! 
Depending on your local gun market, I agree with the Kernel's price range. If you are asking for a face-to-face, private or retail sale, I would guess closer to $650 or slightly more. That is close to the current selling price of a new 6" 686-6, but many would consider your -1 to be more desirable for the reasons stated above. However, for this and many other models the 6" goes for the least. 3, 2.5, 4 and 8 3/8" versions all go for more on average.
For future reference, here is a post showing places to look for S & W revolver ID information:
http://smith-wessonforum.com/s-w-antiques/326458-identify-your-gun.html
Be sure to stop by again with other S & W questions.
Depending on your local gun market, I agree with the Kernel's price range. If you are asking for a face-to-face, private or retail sale, I would guess closer to $650 or slightly more. That is close to the current selling price of a new 6" 686-6, but many would consider your -1 to be more desirable for the reasons stated above. However, for this and many other models the 6" goes for the least. 3, 2.5, 4 and 8 3/8" versions all go for more on average.
For future reference, here is a post showing places to look for S & W revolver ID information:
http://smith-wessonforum.com/s-w-antiques/326458-identify-your-gun.html
Be sure to stop by again with other S & W questions.
Green Frog
Member
Oddly enough, I personally placed a small premium on the 6" barrel when I was looking for my 686. I knew it would be limited to range and target use (and perhaps a rare hunt in the woods) so I wanted the advantage of the greater sight radius. Each barrel length has its adherents and detractors, so find someone looking for what you have, not what is the "most desirable" to the market at large. BTW, my 686 is a no dash, no M and cost me $550 without the grips (and of course no box and docs) about 2 years ago, and I was happy to get it at that time.. Like the Kernel, I would evaluate the one in the OP (assuming nice condition) at a minimum of $650 and perhaps somewhat more on a good day. JMHO, of course and YMMV.
Froggie
Froggie
