Hi, I have a S&W 686. The gun is over 20 years old and I have been shooting it on and off for many years. I use light loads almost all the time in the gun. As of late I have been having a problem with an empty shell getting caught under the extractor star and then being forced back into the chamber. I know this can happen when you don't have the gun in a vertical position when you extract the rounds but I do for the most part and this has not happened before. The parts of the gun seem alright, no excessive end shake in the cylinder, the extractor star is not loose, it does not seem worn, ect... What can be causing this? It might be me by not turning the gun up enough but as I said this has not happened in the past. I shot a match last week and this happened twice costing me time to clear it. Any advice would be a great help. Also does anyone know of a good gunsmith on Long Island, NY or any where near that area?
Help, Shell catching under extractor
- Thread starter M Hondo
- Start date
- Joined
- Oct 17, 2006
- Messages
- 8,404
- Reaction score
- 8,492
The light loads may be contributing to the issue. When ejecting the empties, the muzzle should be straight up and the rod operated full length in one continuous motion. Alternatively, point straight up and hold the weapon in the gun hand and strike the ejector rod forcefully with the support hand.
The ejector star can wobble slightly when it gets close to full extraction. If there is a case hanging in one of the chambers because it wasn't completely extracted, it can over ride the rim and then you're in trouble. I suspect you're not moving the ejector rod full length in one motion. Having the muzzle straight up will help with this.
The ejector star can wobble slightly when it gets close to full extraction. If there is a case hanging in one of the chambers because it wasn't completely extracted, it can over ride the rim and then you're in trouble. I suspect you're not moving the ejector rod full length in one motion. Having the muzzle straight up will help with this.
- Joined
- May 2, 2012
- Messages
- 6,704
- Reaction score
- 13,253
- City & State/Province
- Evansville, Indiana USA
If your cylinder is the older type with the extractor guide pins (2) you might check to see if they are both still in place. Loosing one can cause the problem you describe. Pins are located in the cylinder body under the extractor and interface with the two small holes in the extractor itself.
Gravity is your friend. Hit the rod hard & fast, and let it go immediately. Do not hold it down. Barrel up when ejecting. If the ejector does not remove the emptys, one may be sticking in the chamber. See if all are loose after firing - if not, clean that chamber completely till there is no hang-ups. Remember - let go of the rod right away after ejecting.
