Holster for 686 3"

Joined
Mar 9, 2011
Messages
3
Reaction score
1
Hello everyone. I have been searching frantically for a 3" holster for my 686. I am new to S&W's, and therefore have no experience with the available holsters for them. Can anyone recommend a company and style of holster for a 686 with 3" barrel. I will be carrying as my side arm while pig hunting and camping next weekend. Because of that, I really need to find a quality holster that is readily available.

Thanks in advance,
Reload
 
Register to hide this ad
I was going to suggest you hit a few gunshows and dig through the boxes of $10 holsters, you try one out and if you don't like the way it works then your only out a few bucks and pick up another $10 holster until you find the style that suits you, but since you seem to be pressed for time I would just head off to the gun stores and look for a Bianchi, Desantis, Safariland, or Galco field holster. Your local store may have an old box of used duty holsters, they are generally dirt cheap and of very good quality. They are not very good for CCW but will work just fine for the field.
 
Last edited:
Welcome to the forum.

Try to find a Bass Pro or Gander Mountain store they should have some ballistic holsters that will work. WalMart has also started carrying a cheap but good copy of an Uncle Mike.
 
Reloadyour9:

Lobo Gunleather (member and good egg) can fix you up: lobogunleather.com.

Tucker makes a nice, tuckable IWB holster but I doubt that he has any in stock. http:// rlcompanyusa.stores.yahoo.net/index.html

Welcome to the forum, too! Good people here.

Chris
 
Three inch barrels are a little hard to find holsters for. For leather look at Desantis or Galco, for nylon look at Bianchi. Also look at holsters for the Ruger GP 100 3", they are real close in size but you might have to modify the holster a little to clear the adjustable rear sight on the 686.
 
Still waiting on the mail, but I just bought one of these for my 3" 686 (seven shot). Note: the cylinder is the same size in both the six and seven shot so don't be detered if the holster only says it fits a six-shooter. I will post a photo when I get it.

Comp-tac Belt Holster
 
you need the holster asap, maybe there are some "buy it now" deals on ebay. i recently bought this one off of ebay fairly cheap, and the 3" 686 fits nice. the seller had several of the very same holsters listed.
 

Attachments

  • 002.JPG
    002.JPG
    158.5 KB · Views: 480
  • 003.jpg
    003.jpg
    107.6 KB · Views: 413
  • 005.jpg
    005.jpg
    79.6 KB · Views: 348
Last edited:
you need the holster asap, maybe there are some "buy it now" deals on ebay. i recently bought this one off of ebay fairly cheap, and the 3" 686 fits nice. the seller had several of the very same holsters listed.

This, or a cheapy from Bass Pro or Gander Mtn to get you thru next weekend. Then I would check out Lobo & Simply Rugged. They're pretty much the only two I use anymore, but you'll have to wait a few weeks on their fine work.

Come to think of it, Simply Rugged does have a section on their site called "Gear to Go" or something like that. It's holsters that are already made and ready to ship. You might get lucky.
 
Still waiting on the mail, but I just bought one of these for my 3" 686 (seven shot). Note: the cylinder is the same size in both the six and seven shot so don't be detered if the holster only says it fits a six-shooter. I will post a photo when I get it.

Comp-tac Belt Holster

The cylinders are the same size but the shape and position of the flutes are not the same. The Milt Sparks holster that I have is custom made for the 7 shot cylinder. A six shot gun will fit, I've tried it, but it doesn't fit as securely as the 7 shot it was designed for...
 
Holster

Last August I ordered a PMK holster from Milton Sparks for my S&W 686+ 3 inch barrel. It arrived last week and it is sweet. While this won't be my primary carry gun, during the recent cold weather I have had it with me most of the time.

Sparks looks to be a very good holster for me and looks to be worth the wait.
 
I have a milt sparks summer special for my 686 and a street combat holster from El Paso Saddlery. Both very good holsters. The milt sparks took a little over six months to get, but it is a really nice and srprisingly easy to wear. The el paso holster is good too, The leather is softer, but VERY nice and comfy.
 
wow, talk about leading the man in the wrong direction.....Fobus? Uncle mikes? going to Wal-Mart to get a holster??.....please don't make that mistake, friends don't let friends wear cheap holsters!

Good holsters are expensive, you just bought a nice gun and should get a decent holster to compliment it. 3 Inch guns are indeed harder to find holsters for, but if you look hard enough you will find a good quality leather rig. Galco does not offer a factory 3 inch holster, but they will trim a 4 inch one down to fit a 3 inch gun, they do this in their custom shop. They do charge extra for this but it might be worth it to get a good holster that fits your gun well.
 
Try Gould & Goodrich. I have a 3 inch model 66 that is double action only with a bobbed hammer. Found one of their holsters that works great.
 
I was going to suggest you hit a few gunshows and dig through the boxes of $10 holsters, you try one out and if you don't like the way it works then your only out a few bucks and pick up another $10 holster until you find the style that suits you

Good advice from one of many that have a damn "boxful of WORTHLESS HOLSTERS!!"
 
This is the Simply Rugged Sourdough I have for my 2-1/2" 686. I bought it with the IWB straps, which are removeable. Great holster!
SN852250.jpg
 
Since you stated that you wanted a holster quickly, Galco makes their "Silhouette" holster which will work well.

IMG_2093.jpg


The barrel will be exposed, and this type is less-than-ideal for concealed carry, but it should suffice for your immediate needs.

IMG_2357.jpg

IMG_2356.jpg


Kramer makes an excellent holster for the 3" S&W 686. The one in the photograph is horsehide.
 
Lobo

DSC_0037sm.jpg


I'll second Lobogunleather.com, good quality and reasonable prices. The 686 3" in the middle is from Lobo...
 
Back
Top