I love Jamaica Hellfire Sauce, the hottest variety, which is of course no longer available in the Cleveland area (that I know of).
I also like Dave's Insanity Sauce... also no longer available.
For a while, I was buying the Tabasco brand habanero sauce... also now unavailable.
For the time being, I can still get Valentina brand habanero sauce at the local Giant Eagle.
I alternate between Tabasco brand and another no-name brand of jalapeno sauce. Chef Hans is GREAT... and now unavailable here.
There used to be an actual hot sauce store in the same strip mall where my favorite local family restaurant is located. They of course closed...
It's my contention that the average Clevelander likes no food with any more taste than the packaging in which it came. They consider mayonnaise on white bread, "spicy ethnic food".