Qualify "stopping power" requirement?
1. Stop them dead in their tracks?
2. Stop them from continuing and make them think twice?
3. Stopping power as in self defense?
4. Stopping power as in home defense?
Each has a "tool" for the job, the proper tool for the job will help ensure sucess more eaisly then trying to make something work that was not intended to do the job.
And although Bulld4wg can assure us that no one wants to take 25 rounds of stinger to the face, and I agree with Bulld4wg on that point, I can assure you that in a low light condition with only an eye blink between you and possibly your last breath, with over 90% of "grevious injury" home defense sceinarios, that all 25 of those rounds will not land on target, if any at all, no matter how bad you are. I investigated a case once where the home owner emptied a whole 30 round 5.56 mag and only one round hit the bad guy (left mid section outside and got mostly flesh and didn't do any real damage, basically a flesh wound thru and thru), at a distance of 28 feet. The combat stress, the low light conditions, lack of experience and training in such situations, the speed of the engagement, the bad guy shooting back, the movement, certainly contributed to the misses. The bad guy firing back hit the home owner four times (two in the left calf, one left hip, one upper right chest). The bad guy has planned his attack and came in thru the dark shadows and the home owner was in the light. Bad guy lived, home owner died. The home owner was a competition shooter, and familiar with the weapon, but he forgot one important thing - range targets do not shoot back and did not account for that.
Unless your trained and experienced at CQB types of engagements, forgo the rifle and choose something that when it does land on target it does some massive damage not only to tissue but also to the central nervous system, to help make sure that you have more eyes blinks left and put the greatest chance back on your side because in almost 100% of situations the bad guy has already mapped out their plan for their best chances and most times has the element of suprise on their side. The key to stopping dead in the tracks is to do one of two things, and perferably both at the same time:
1. Massive damage causing critical body funtions to cease operating properly or at all, immediately.
2. Massive neurological collapse of the central nervous system.
You have roughly maybe a second to do this (and possibly less), so make it count. Its very unlikely the bad guy will put the element of suprise on your side, so you don't have much time at all.
You want something that will do that. If you don't do those two things in those situations then your chances decrease by almost 97% that the person will be stopped before they have a chance to do some harm to you or your family. If you had time to put in some well placed shots like you do on the range then a .22 might do it for you somewhat, or at least make them think twice, but in home defense or self defense its pretty unlikely the bad guy is going to oblige you while you get all stanced up and take careful aim so you gotta do it fast and strike the target quickly, hard, and decisively. As one of our old instructors used to say "When it happens its going to be sudden, swift, and violent. All that remains to be known is who it happens to."
Home defense: Shotgun - 12 ga - 000 buck
Self Defense carry : 40 or 45 cal with Extream Shock ammo
45 cal:
Extreme Shock - The World's Most Advanced Ammunition
40 cal:
Extreme Shock - The World's Most Advanced Ammunition