I am looking for input on this comparison guide for grip style.

Joined
Feb 8, 2009
Messages
286
Reaction score
451
Location
Morehead KY
I have decided to write a comparison report for those interested in grips and as a reference for the grips I make. I frequently get asked "are those grips like the factory grips in size?" Not everyone has had access to the grips i frequently mention or reference. My grips are based on these proven designs. I feel there are enough designs out there to accomodate most everyone whether it be hand size or shooting style. Attributes of these grips can be mixed to suit the purpose.
GEDC0811_zps14210ddd.jpg


The Boot grips popularity can be attributed to Craig Spegel. People have been modifying grips to be more compact for decades. But it was Spegel who popularized a standard design wich has one finger groove and tapers at the bottom to allow the pinky to be placed in a comfortable spot.
GEDC0809_zpsadf6166e.jpg


Fitz gunfighter design is the most similar in dimensions to spegel grips. They differ in that they are not as tapered at the botton, and have more area below the gripframe. They also sport 2 nub like fingergrooves that do not acually force you finger into one spot ,this area is also less narrow than the spegel design (which may dissipate recoil better). Many similarities are obvious in the picture. Pretty much every other dimension of these grips are within a couple milimeters.
GEDC0817_zps8b162e50.jpg

One exception to this is the J frame Fitz gunfighter as seen here :
GEDC0886_zps68ada205.jpg

These are for a square butt J frame.
GEDC0882_zps26d2c270.jpg


Franzite grips are copy of Walter Ropers design. Back in the late 40's and early 50's, if you wanted Roper grips but couldn't afford them, you bought Franzite.
GEDC0849_zps2d5435dd.jpg

GEDC0845_zps0201d820.jpg

There are variations in the design and my favorite is one that has a groove for your trigger finger that is similar to the Fitz gunfighter design. Franzite and Fitz are frquently compared because they both are made of plastic and offer thumbrest target designs.
This is where the similarities end. Franzite grips are considerably more narrow and slimmer than the Fitz design. Also see the picture below that shows a comparison of factory target grips (left), franzite grips(middle) Kurac "Cokes"(right)
.
GEDC0837_zps165b882b.jpg

GEDC0857_zps83f3aa4b.jpg

GEDC0831_zps1b393b70.jpg

GEDC0823_zps7cbcd26b.jpg

Fitz Ten-O is a thumbrest target design that is appropriate for people with med-large hands. This design has been copied by companies like Sile and Jay Scott. It has a covered backstrap. The K Frame version is smaller than the N frame by a considerable margin. Below arw photo that shows a k frame panel on one side and a n frame on the other.
GEDC0861_zpscae2cfee.jpg


GEDC0862_zpsbc2a1bee.jpg

I have small hands. A k frame Ten-O is about right to allow me to fire both single and double action. N frame is too large dor me to fire double action. A person with large hands may consider this size just right.

Pachmayr made a Bill Jordan grip similar to Herretts Jordan trooper. These grips are frequently praised by people with large hands. They offer a high hold with a covered backstrap.
GEDC0866_zpsee5f3b59.jpg

GEDC0864_zps82f9612a.jpg
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Great post, I have developed an interest in vintage grips. I used to never give aftermarket grips, especially plastic ones any consideration until I held some mounted on a gun. The Fitz target grip is just about 3/8" to short for my hand but I really like the feel. The Jordan Trooper grips are maybe a 1/4" to big all around. My problem with wood early grips is that most were custom made for whomever ordered them and getting a pair that fits your hand well is about impossible it seems.I have a few pair of really nice old custom grips I need to start a thread about so I can get an ID on them. I have been reading your posts about grips as they come up and I really like how you have an open mind about grip design and are willing to take input from others.Keep up the good work.
 
Many grip makers had the purchaser send in a tracing of their gun hand, in later years a xerox copy, and some with measurements of the thickness of the hand in specific locations. I had a pair of target grips made by Vitarbo for a High Standard Victor. These fit very snug for bullseye shooting.

IMG_0536.jpg
 
Nice post..... just an FYI.

Spegel also has "extended boot grips" which extend about 3/8" (IIRC )below the grip frame. they are just a bit shorted than Smith Target grips but give just enough extra length to get a good 3 finger grip.

These work very well..... and look good... look "great" if you get Craig to checker them... on guns with 4-6" barrels.
 
I wonder how one would go about transferring the data from a hand tracing into a set of grips that would fit that person well. I read that Keith Brown has 8 different ways to fit the grips based on a tracing.
 
Measurement from the web of the hand to the tip of the finger is one way. This would determine how much area behind the hammer ( so to place your finger properly on the trigger). I could use my hand as the control( smallest), then with fabric tape measure, add the difference in circumference... per digit. I would also need the whoever sends a tracing to mark their knuckles, just a small tickmark would work.
 
Back
Top