As a kid, I had the good fortune of having a dad who (among other things) was a firearms dealer. My dad, grandpa, and uncles had been gun traders for years before I was born too, so I've had access to hundreds and hundreds of firearms during my lifetime. I greatly admired these guys and their friends, and would sit for hours listening to all of them talk about guns; knowing when to be silent, and when to ask questions helped me learn a whole lot. I read everything I could find to boost my knowledge to fill in the blank spots that these guys were unsure of. I fired their guns, used their handloads, and built up a lot of my own recipes as newer powders and different types of bullets became available. As a kid my day went like this: Up before 5 to feed and water the cattle (winter time), breakfast reading Keith, O'Connor, Ruark, etc., off to school, back at home shooting, checking on the cattle, etc. till dark, then school work, reloading, or reading until sleepytime.
Here's what I've learned from the pre-Internet days through now: 1. You have about as much of a chance now of picking a lemon out of the bunch now as you did in 1978- you just have more options, currently. 2. Unless you purchase it specifically not to shoot, your "holy grail" gun may not live up to your expectations. 3. No single firearm will ever fit ALL of your 'possible' needs, but you CAN work with loads and such to make it better suited to what you need it for most of the time. 4. Hold on dearly to the gun that fits you best and shoots best for you, then explore its limitations with handloads until you know exactly what it is capable of as far as accuracy, reliability, and shooting comfort are concerned.
All of the above yap that you had to read has brought you down to the only part that directly answers the OP, and this is just an opinion on a gun from "some guy on the internet". About 4 or 5 years ago I bought a new 315NG and have put enough reloads through it (tried to keep track in case I had any problems, but quit after 3000 or so rounds), testing it to see what it and I can do together to perform harmoniously. I can truly say that this gun is the gun that covers 90% of what I need my gun to do in my environment. The rest is covered by a 2.5" 638, a .41, or a rifle or shotgun.
Sorry for the long post, but I've been waiting for this thread to appear for awhile!