If you could only have 1 J frame, what would it be?
- Thread starter Eagle1*
- Start date
Register to hide this ad
Judging from my 442 that has quite a bit of its finish worn off from riding in a pocket holster, it must be the one I use the most, and would keep no matter what. Grab and pocket for a quick run to store.
My next favorite is a steel 3" model 60 that rides in a Galco holster..
fortunately, limiting myself to one J frame is silly.
My next favorite is a steel 3" model 60 that rides in a Galco holster..
fortunately, limiting myself to one J frame is silly.
Thinking of all the J Frames I have, my Mod 63 would be the most versatile one.
Even in the PDR of MA, it's hard to imagine just one, but a square-butt Model 37 would be my answer. With a Tyler, of course. I would prefer nickel.
69HEMI-R/T
Member
I actually carry my factory-nickeled 442 (around 1995) the most but if I could only have one: S&W 640 would be my choice.
DD357
Member
Think I'll jump on Practical's 60-9 train.
- Joined
- Dec 2, 2012
- Messages
- 3,345
- Reaction score
- 5,561
3" 60-15 for me. It would be tough to lose the 442, though...
ParadiseRoad
Member
...if I could only have one...it would be the one I have...no dash Model 36...
Well I have 4 J frames, making a choice like this is hard.
I think I would stick with my Model 60, purchased new in the mid 1970s. I carried it a lot for years, worked on the triger pull to make it "comfortable". Gun has been a 100% reliable and is as accurate as a gun like this can be.
Second choice was my 642(no lock) but as stated it is the old 60 for me
!
I think I would stick with my Model 60, purchased new in the mid 1970s. I carried it a lot for years, worked on the triger pull to make it "comfortable". Gun has been a 100% reliable and is as accurate as a gun like this can be.
Second choice was my 642(no lock) but as stated it is the old 60 for me
!
revolver686
Member
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2012
- Messages
- 184
- Reaction score
- 289
If I had to choose one it would be my 2 inch Model 60. Stainless steel for durability and a little - but not too much - extra weight for shooting comfort
It gives me the option of shooting .357, and the ability to shoot single action if I want.
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
It gives me the option of shooting .357, and the ability to shoot single action if I want.
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
Richard Simmons
Member
M49 for sure. A 3" if I could find one but a 2" will do just fine. Snag free with the option of SA if needed or desired.
Edmo
US Veteran
Only one???
OK, my choices in order of which ones to keep are:
- The model 60 no dash on the left.
- Followed by the 642-1 on top right.
- Lastly the 640-1 Pro Series on the bottom right.
Why? I've owned the 60 since the mid -80s so I'm attached to it. As a bonus it is a great shooter.
The 642 is light enough to pocket carry without pulling my shorts down.
My 640 Pro Series has made four trips back to Springfield to fix poor workmanship issues. I think they have finished building it, but who knows what will go wrong with it next! For that reason my 640 would be the first to go...
Edmo
OK, my choices in order of which ones to keep are:
- The model 60 no dash on the left.
- Followed by the 642-1 on top right.
- Lastly the 640-1 Pro Series on the bottom right.
Why? I've owned the 60 since the mid -80s so I'm attached to it. As a bonus it is a great shooter.
The 642 is light enough to pocket carry without pulling my shorts down.
My 640 Pro Series has made four trips back to Springfield to fix poor workmanship issues. I think they have finished building it, but who knows what will go wrong with it next! For that reason my 640 would be the first to go...
Edmo
Three inch 60-10......357, adjustable sights.......... think "micro-686".
Small enough to carry concealed....... and still do double duty as a "Kit Gun"
Small enough to carry concealed....... and still do double duty as a "Kit Gun"
snowman.45
Member
While I really would miss my M60 no dash and my 640-1, I'd have to take my 340 M&P as it is my most carried revolver. As others have said about their various J-frame models, it's light weight and size make it great for concealment. Now, I've got to say that .357 is punishing through it, but having the capability to use magnum is a (rarely used) plus.
kthom
Member
I've got it, thankfully among others. It's the Model 640-1 made in the mid 90's. It's my all time favorite J Frame and would be the last to go and only then under great duress!
The one I have... 442-1 it's my spring/summer carry
but S&W wish list?
A J frame size and weight 44 special!!!
.... but the charter will do for now for my fall/winter carry until one day my wildest dreams are granted
dcopper
Member
Model 60-7 all day every day. But why limit yourself to just 1?
Similar threads
