Is your Shield brand new? If so, you may need to use higher power ammo to fully cycle the slide on a tight new gun. The various brands of ammo you are using all may be fairly weak, especially if they're 115 grain. I suggest trying Winchester NATO 9mm 124 grain ammo. It is easy to find, it's powerful, and best of all, it's fairly cheap. It's also the most accurate for me in my 9mm Shield.
Also, check the position of your thumb while shooting. It could be hitting the slide stop during recoil, inadvertently locking the slide back.
Another possibility is the recoil spring assembly. If it's not perfectly aligned, straight and level, when reassembling your Shield, it might not always cycle the slide. My Shield 9 came with a bent rear spring retainer disk on the recoil spring assembly which made it difficult to align properly. The result was a bunch of failures to eject.
Although unlikely, you may have a weak recoil spring assembly. If your Shield is really easy to rack, your recoil spring is weak. Shield 9s are notorious for being one of the hardest-racking semi-autos around if their recoil springs are at normal strength.
Those are my ideas off the top of my head. Other Forum members should be along to give their thoughts as well.
Finally, welcome to the Forum!