New Guy Tip:
Most civilian market AR-15's are intentionally over-gassed. This is done to ensure that the rifle will cycle a wide variety of common off the shelf commercially available ammunition. Firearms manufacturers don't want their customer service lines flooded with calls about rifles not working with off the shelf ammo.
If you are trying to alter your rifle's ejection pattern to more closely match that infamous chart, what you are really doing is altering the cyclic rate of your firearm. You can either do this by altering the static mass (carbine BCG, full auto BCG, buffer weights) or the progressive resistance (buffer spring weights, hydraulic buffers) on which the combustion gasses must overcome to cycle the action.
*NOTE* When you alter your rifle's cyclic rate, you can induce malfunction. I've seen many people complain about their rifles not being reliable. The problem isn't the rifle. The problem is the nut behind the trigger's lack of common sense and basic physics.
Practical Advice:
I've been down this road. If your rifle kicks out spent cases and doesn't malfunction, you're good to go no matter what some stupid chart says. I see no point in narrowing the range of ammo I can fire out of my acclaimed S.H.T.F. world ending emergency survival rifle.
Hypocritical Advice:
I tinker. I've tried every buffer weight/type, buffer spring, and a variety of BCG's. If you do have the urge to tinker, I'll give you a shortcut.
- Fail Zero semi-auto BCG
- Damage Industries Silicone Chrome buffer spring.
- AR-Restor Hydraulic Buffer.
The Fail Zero semi-auto BCG is NiBx treated. You don't need to oil it. Cleaning it is a quick wipe with a terry cloth towel. No scraping, no picking, nada.
The Damage Industries Silicone Chrome Buffer Spring cuts down the noise and offers longer life.
The AR-Restor Hydraulic Buffer offers progressive resistance against the load applied to it. No messing with trying out several different buffer weights. I maintain the ability to cycle a wide range of commonly available ammo. It also dampens the perceived recoil impulse.
In addition to a good 2-Stage trigger and an optic, these three items are the only other truly worthwhile upgrades I've ever made to an AR-15.