D, I'm curious as to what you are thinking regarding bad tactics. My understanding is that the FBI used several units to stakeout some banks they felt were likely to get robbed by Platt and Matix just off the South Dixie Highway in Kendall, Florida on the morning of April 11th 1986. SA McNeil, the agent in charge of the operation, believed that based on past behaviour, the two BGs were likely to commit a robbery in that locale at that time. Shortly after the stakeout began, agents Dove and Grogan spotted the suspect's vehicle and began to follow it. As other units were converging, the perps made three right hand turns, so there was at that time no doubt that they knew they were being followed. IIRC, SAs Manauzzi in one car, Mireles and Hanlon in another, McNeil in his car, and Grogan and Dove in theirs, at that time ran the BGs off the road. SA McNeil decided to make the stop because he felt that with the stakeout having been "made", the perps would change their MO, thus sending the FBI efforts to apprehend them back to the drawing board. In the meantime other robberys would occur and innocent lives would be lost.
Obviously we both know that SA McNeil understood that the situation was less than ideal to stop Platt and Matix. I'm not a cop, so while I tend to support SA McNeil's judgement, realizing that he didn't have hindsight on his side, perhaps I'm missing something. Is there a law enforcement principal, or protocol that he broke that could have prevented this tragedy?
Good points, Flop...allow me to explain. (Keep in mind that I wasn't there and "second guess" with an eye to keeping such from happening again.)
The agents were looking for a specific vehicle...they found it. Soon thereafter S/A's Grogan and Dove were "made." With the number of vehicles the FBI had deployed, the "made" factor could have been obviated by simply disengaging...make Platt and Mattix believe they were not being followed. They did not. Soon after being "made," Grogan said "felony car stop." However, they intentionally collided with the suspects. That is not how the stop should have proceeded. (Whenever cars collide, pit maneuvers notwithstanding, there is no way whatsoever to know how the vehicles will be located post-collision.)
The stop was wholly unmanaged thus vehicles ended up too close to the bad guys, guns left unsecured on car seats "disappeared," agents with long/auto weapons never got to the scene 'til it was over, etc. S/A Grogan lost his eyeglasses and was essentially blind, too. Bear in mind the FBI knew the suspects were heavily armed and had used deadly force. None of the agents involved in the shootout had a rifle available. Other agents in the surveillance did but they were among those who arrived after the fact.
The agents ended up in a neighborhood and witnesses called 9-1-1 not knowing LEO's were involved. Ditto Miami-Dade PD who should have been involved but were not.
I could go on and on. Two Special Agents were killed; others were seriously wounded. Absent S/A Mirales' truly heroics efforts, Platt and Mattix could have "won" the battle and escaped though both would likely have died soon thereafter.
This was a battle that should not have been lost but was.
Be safe.