GtownGeorge
Member
- Joined
- Jun 27, 2013
- Messages
- 277
- Reaction score
- 405
That's why you are so effin smart!!!!!!
Looking for a second firearm
- Thread starter Rob224
- Start date
That's why you are so effin smart!!!!!!
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2005
- Messages
- 8,020
- Reaction score
- 7,100
Full size M&P in 9mm seems the obvious choice for more pleasant range shooting.
treiz
Member
+1 for the full size M&P 9mm
shakyshoot
Member
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2013
- Messages
- 610
- Reaction score
- 494
Mark me down as another solidly pro-gun liberal.
How bout a .22? Good inexpensive practice and lots of fun. I've been shooting about 250 rounds on a range trip. Couldn't afford that with centerfire, even if I did reload, which I don't.
I agree. I'd suggest you look at a Ruger SR1911 commander. If you want to spend a little more, look at the S&W E series SC commanders. But if you don't want to go the 1911 route, then I'd suggest an M&P45c. Whatever you do, don't go near any
3rd Gens.. No cure for them.
lhump1961
US Veteran
I would go with a 4" 586 or 686. Very versatile and gives you a totally different shooting experience. If you can master DA on a good revolver then you can shoot most anything IMHO.
It depends entirely on what you want to use it for.
You're already covered for concealed carry, so for a "2nd" gun, do you really need another? Perhaps a smaller backup gun would be better put off for later as a 3rd or 4th.
I'd recommend going with something a little more versatile and larger than a shield, either for home defense or having fun or practice at the range.
While I do like a good 1911 .45, I'd rather have more capacity for a defense weapon. A good choice for maximum versatility would be an M&P40 in either the full-size or compact models. You can always add a 9mm conversion barrel, and use the full-size or even extended magazines.
Until you've been shooting for awhile, you probably won't know exactly how you want to go in the future. This would give you about the best chance to figure it out at minimum cost.
You're already covered for concealed carry, so for a "2nd" gun, do you really need another? Perhaps a smaller backup gun would be better put off for later as a 3rd or 4th.
I'd recommend going with something a little more versatile and larger than a shield, either for home defense or having fun or practice at the range.
While I do like a good 1911 .45, I'd rather have more capacity for a defense weapon. A good choice for maximum versatility would be an M&P40 in either the full-size or compact models. You can always add a 9mm conversion barrel, and use the full-size or even extended magazines.
Until you've been shooting for awhile, you probably won't know exactly how you want to go in the future. This would give you about the best chance to figure it out at minimum cost.
Second gun for HD that is a full size revolver and bigger caliber. I'd suggest a S&W model 625. This is my most desired next gun but I've completed my GtownGeorge trifecta already. Second gun perhaps also for carry I'd suggest a k-frame in the 2" to 3" barrel form.
jfp357
Member
Second gun? You wont stop there. For home defense and carry the 442 J frame is my choice(.38 spec). You can carry concealed year round. For your third gun you gotta have a 1911. Go back and count how many have recommended the 1911. It is advise well given. One shot with a 1911 you will be sold. I got a Remington 1911 in stainless a 1000 rounds and no problems. IMHO
mafbloggerdanny
Member
You say that the shield is the first gun you have ever purchased...are you also a new shooter ?
If that's the case i would recommend a full size M&P in 9mm to stick with the same ammo type...unless you like the feel of a 1911 in .45, then maybe go with that...
as others have said... your 2nd or even third purchases PROBABLY won't be your last anyways!
If that's the case i would recommend a full size M&P in 9mm to stick with the same ammo type...unless you like the feel of a 1911 in .45, then maybe go with that...
as others have said... your 2nd or even third purchases PROBABLY won't be your last anyways!
speedyquad
Member
this is my next purchase as i have a sw40ve(sigma 40) and a m&p40c.
i carry the 40c every time i leave the house...it is a great 2nd firearm. shield would have been the 2nd had they had a 40. they only had the 9mm at the time, so the 40c was the winner for the day. as matter of fact, i've had a few chances to purchase a shield 40 since and have turned it down as it is not that different from the 40c. i say go for a revolver...i have a 586-no dash(no dash means it was the first incarnation/generation) that i inherited from my dad. it's been fired very little. it makes me want to buy one to shoot, but like i said, the 1911 is next.
i don't think you would want to go smaller than either the shield or 40c as a carry gun. someone, in kind of a tongue in cheek way, said to me once-"the shorter the barrel, the bigger the target needs to be".
When it comes to good people I`m Liberal, when it comes to Government and Corporations I`m Conservative and when it comes to guns I`m always looking for another one.
I have 3 M&P`s and lookng for a Shield9mm. since you have the Shield I`d pick up a M&Pcompact with the x-grip and 17 round mags. It`s a great gun and has 12 to 17 round mags. Or just get the fulll size for home and target. Or just buy both, you`ll probably end up doing that anyway.:
This will be a no no but a slick smallish carry gun is the Ruger LC9 with the side slide mounted LaserLyte [ this laser fits on the side and isn't bulky like the front mounted ones]
I have 3 M&P`s and lookng for a Shield9mm. since you have the Shield I`d pick up a M&Pcompact with the x-grip and 17 round mags. It`s a great gun and has 12 to 17 round mags. Or just get the fulll size for home and target. Or just buy both, you`ll probably end up doing that anyway.:
This will be a no no but a slick smallish carry gun is the Ruger LC9 with the side slide mounted LaserLyte [ this laser fits on the side and isn't bulky like the front mounted ones]
kozmic
Member
I believe I would would sway you toward a mid-sized K, or L, or even Ruger SP101/GP100 revolver with a 3-4" barrel. Nice, used revolvers are usually plentiful and shouldn't be disregarded. A 357/.38s would compliment your Shield 9. It wouldn't be a great daily carry but would make a perfect HD piece. Simple, reliable, fun at the range.......
If the idea of carry is a really high priority still then the same logic in a J frame (not necessarily a .357) like a 442, LCR or a used M36 or M60 would be a nice addition to your stable.
The suggestion of a 1911 is solid. Rock Island, Ruger and Springfield are all making good quality "entry" 1911's in that sub 1000 buck range.
If the idea of carry is a really high priority still then the same logic in a J frame (not necessarily a .357) like a 442, LCR or a used M36 or M60 would be a nice addition to your stable.
The suggestion of a 1911 is solid. Rock Island, Ruger and Springfield are all making good quality "entry" 1911's in that sub 1000 buck range.
geodimeter
Member
In order I would buy a 6" 586 or 686 revolver and then a steel auto like a Browning Hi Power. Both are much more enjoyable to shoot and sharpen your skillset with than a Shield (nothing against the Shield, I love my .40). All the same caliber so you can assemble a cleaning kit, etc. with minor expense. Additionally if you want to get into reloading the .38 special/.357 magnum gives a lot of choices. So get the revolver and start picking up your brass. Good shooting!
