So I've been carrying my wife's G19 as a backpack/truck/desk drawer/occasional CCW. I also have a Shield that gets carried often as deep concealed but I really don't like it nor am I very proficient with it like I am the Glock, mostly because of my very large hands. My wife decided she is repossessing the G19 for her EDC which leaves me needing to buy another gun, I know, terrible. The M&P compact feels amazing in my hand and seems that it will be very concealable which leaves me with just one question, 9mm or 40? Not another 9 vs 40, but yes, in this gun just by the numbers is there any benefit to 40 in this short barrel?
M&P compact
- Thread starter TankTop5
- Start date
Register to hide this ad
rock_castle
Member
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2013
- Messages
- 249
- Reaction score
- 178
This is a good idea.
So are you saying the M&P compact isn't that reliable? I've got plenty of mags for the G19 and at the amount I shoot it no parts should wear out in my lifetime. Back to the M&P, just watched some YouTube videos on short barrel ammo, looks like Federal 147+P is the go to round and 40 cal doesn't add anything of substance to this firearm.
I'm in Colorado and it's a pretty dry state, how does the M&P 9c hold up to the elements?
I'm in Colorado and it's a pretty dry state, how does the M&P 9c hold up to the elements?
- Joined
- Dec 2, 2012
- Messages
- 3,349
- Reaction score
- 5,577
No one said it's not reliable. Most current production autos are, right out of the box.
They were pointing out that, if you like the G19, and you're wife already has one, why not get another?
Now if you want a new and different type of pistol, then I think you're making a fine choice. FWIW, I prefer 9 over 40 in any pistol when available.
They were pointing out that, if you like the G19, and you're wife already has one, why not get another?
Now if you want a new and different type of pistol, then I think you're making a fine choice. FWIW, I prefer 9 over 40 in any pistol when available.
MichiganScott
Member
With modern bullets the 9mm gives up little to the .40. Besides, the 9mm recoil is less, so follow up shots can be quicker.
Not that they are common, but all of the spontaneous disassemblies (kabooms) I've heard of with the M&P and Glock have been with the .40's.
Not that they are common, but all of the spontaneous disassemblies (kabooms) I've heard of with the M&P and Glock have been with the .40's.
I like my 9c and it shoots great. It is very comfortable to carry and I have not had any issues with it after about 600 round of use. It boils down to what you are the most comfortable with and shoot the best.
Arik
Member
Why not rent one first before dropping several hundred dollars on it? This way if you don't lime it you're not out any money
Also, if the G19 works for you why not just buy one?
Also, if the G19 works for you why not just buy one?
Where's that popcorn guy?
I love my 40 Compact, have for quite a while. I have no problem with the so called "40 flip". A firm grip & good stance goes a long way towards taking care of that, I guess...I like 180gr. JHP, myself.
I love my 40 Compact, have for quite a while. I have no problem with the so called "40 flip". A firm grip & good stance goes a long way towards taking care of that, I guess...I like 180gr. JHP, myself.
Last edited:
Fox4506
Member
I agree that a Glock 19 is a good choice since you already like it and you can swap mags etc, with the wife.
With that said I have a 40c and I love it. Recoil isn't a problem for me either.
Fox
With that said I have a 40c and I love it. Recoil isn't a problem for me either.
Fox
40 cal isn't an issue for me in the right gun, had a G23 that was a blast to shoot as long as it was heavier bullets. Glocks are great guns but I'm getting a little chunky and it makes the Glock uncomfortable. I do need to shoot the MP9c first but I've handled them and they fit my hand near perfect. I want to get it in 40 but I'm just a little concerned with muzzle flip and follow up shots, however it's very close in size to the G19, should be similar.
walkin' trails
Member
- Joined
- Dec 16, 2006
- Messages
- 1,372
- Reaction score
- 824
I have a 9c and have carried G19s and 23s in the past. The G19 is an efficient size. I have come to prefer the ergonomics and trigger of the 9c, and carry year -round in all seasons .Never worried about rust or effects from the elements with Glocks or M&Ps.
Well, in regards to 9mm vs .40S&W, here's a nice test on a variety of ammo shot out of short barreled handguns which include a 9C.
Handgun Self-Defense Ammunition - Ballistic Testing Data
Handgun Self-Defense Ammunition - Ballistic Testing Data
ca survivor
Member
- Joined
- Nov 22, 2013
- Messages
- 330
- Reaction score
- 85
moose1953us
Member
9mm ammo is less expensive than .40, 9mm magazines hold more rounds, and at self defense distances the 9 is just as effective. It seems to me the advantage is with the 9.
