Mid-Range 110 and 125 gr .357 Mag suitability for '80's K-frames?

Agree. I think "internet experts" have promulgated this story. I bought a model 19-5 around 1983 and proceeded to put thousands of 110 grain and 125 grain handloads through it propelled by Elmer Kieth memorial loads of W296 or 2400. It eventually wore the nickel plating away on the top strap but never did it crack a forcing cone.

I don't know anything about cracked forcing cones, have never seen one and don't know the cause of such; just can't see a use for light bullets in .357.
 
The 110 and 125 grain hyper velocity loads in 357 Magnum came about in the 1970's and 80's, an era when jacketed bullet expansion required very high velocity. Super-Vel was the first, then Federal, Remington, and Winchester came out with their versions of hyper velocity, light weight bullet loads.

The hyper velocity 110 grain loads tended to have fantastic expansion, but poor penetration against 2-legged miscreants. The 125 grain loads still had fantastic expansion, but would also penetrate well and quickly became the load of choice for law enforcement. With modern jacket materials and the ability to make jackets with long, deep skives, hyper velocity is no longer needed for reliable expansion.
 
Back
Top