Model 58, Is there any excitment for these?

Is there a 41 Special and why don't people reload?

It seems to me that Model 57/58's would be more popular if they had an alternative loading available such as 357 and 44 mag do. I have seen some loadings for a "non-magnum" 41 caliber load that pushes the bullet along around 875 fps. Are these just reduced 41 mag loads or does someone make a shorter "41 special" case? The guns are beautiful and S&W makes a Model 57 Mountain Gun that is quite tempting, lock and all. I shoot a fixed sight case-colored Model 22-4 that is very accurate and handsome in its own rugged way.

Time constraints are the only reason I could see not to reload for an expensive and hard-ro-find caliber such as 41 mag. A set of dies can be had for as little as $30 and a used single stage press can be picked up on the auction site for $50 or less. As an active shooter I would not own this caliber unless I could reload the ammo.
 
...yes, the lead 210 grain/950 fps load is the original Police Load except that the original police load badly leaded the bore within a cylinder full as the bullet was so soft. Todays reduced power loads are made with hard cast vs. swaged bullets and don't hardly lead at all.

Georgia Arms has good prices on .41 Magnum...

Georgia Arms - Search

Appalachian Ammo also has great prices but their website is offline for some reason. They were just at the Concord, NH Gun Show last month...

Website.com

Their phone number is: (207) 860-2688

Bob
 
I just bought one about 5 minutes ago. Ive been reading this thread and found one for a good price. I have never had a .41. mag. Now for the ammo hunt.



Reed's of ok city and Georgia Arms are good sources < $30 @ 50
 
I have wanted a 58 for many years since I have a fondness for fixed site S&Ws... I found one about a month ago and finally had a chance to load up some 210 lead swc's over some unique...

All I can say is i have a new favorite... POI matches POA.... and it is one of the best shooting guns I have had the pleasure to own.... great mix of power with very manageable recoil....

I had owned a 57, 8 3/8 years ago and only shot hunting loads (i.e. hot loads) in it and I never really cared for the recoil..... just a little too much to go plink with... but with the "police load" it is a whole different ballgame... and one I am glad I gave a chance to again.
 
jdickson397;
Yes, there is such a cartridge as the .41 Special. Seems to me it has even been loaded commercially, but it escapes my memory who made them. I'm pretty sure Starline offers the brass, and of course, any .410 -.411 bullet is useful. Data is available online.

Larry
 
I love my old factory nickel M58....despite being .41 mag. I like mine for the reasons others have mentioned. Namely, its an N-frame, fixed sights, PC magnas and a Tyler T feel great, it balances well and mine has a fantastic DA pull. I really like its narrow hammer spur too.

I like the gun, not the caliber. If it was a .44 special or mag It would be my favorite revolver. Someday I'll have one made up.

.41 mag doesn't do anything that the .44's don't do better IMHO.
 
I traded for this beat up nickel 58 at the Richmond SWCA meeting from our forum owner Lee. I sent it back to S&W and had them renickel it. Now it is too pretty to shoot.

justdone003.jpg
That's like saying a girl is TOO PRETTY TO KISS. No its not, That refreshed model 58 is just begging you to take her to the range . Pretty guns and girls both want to go to the dance and have a good time
 
I love my old factory nickel M58....despite being .41 mag. I like mine for the reasons others have mentioned. Namely, its an N-frame, fixed sights, PC magnas and a Tyler T feel great, it balances well and mine has a fantastic DA pull. I really like its narrow hammer spur too.

I like the gun, not the caliber. If it was a .44 special or mag It would be my favorite revolver. Someday I'll have one made up.

.41 mag doesn't do anything that the .44's don't do better IMHO.

Sure it does. It recoils better. Much more better.
 
That's like saying a girl is TOO PRETTY TO KISS. No its not, That refreshed model 58 is just begging you to take her to the range . Pretty guns and girls both want to go to the dance and have a good time

I'd shoot that pistol enough that she would have to marry me, for fear of being called a woman of the night.:D
 
Back
Top