Yeah, the retainer I received is nothing at all like the Hogue retainer at all. The Hogue retainer is made of polymer and is shaped completely differently, is much larger, and is designed in such a way that it actually interfaces with the frame and is held in place under tension from the mainspring.
Unfortunately, because the Hogue retainer is larger and shaped differently than the retainer that came with the grips, the grips won't go on with the Hogue retainer installed. However, I'm confident that the grips could be easily modified to accommodate the Hogue adapter by simply removing a bit of material from inside the grips, so eventually I'll probably do that as a project, but for now I'm just burned out with it.
There wasn't any packaging at all in the commercial sense, it came wrapped up in bubble wrap inside of a plain paper business envelope with a simple return address bearing no company information.
I've just always sort of assumed that KSD was just making these on the sly then selling them on various websites other than their own in order to get around any potential threat of a lawsuit by Smith & Wesson over unauthorized use of their logo, but given the terrible particle board retainer that mine came with compared to the comparatively nice polymer retainer your genuine KSD grips came with, maybe they are just knockoffs afterall.
Furthermore, it's worth noting that these grips only cost me $50, whereas genuine KSD grips typically sell for $90+ on the official website, so that's more evidence to suggest that they're knockoffs.
I appreciate the offer, but there's really no way to be sure that the genuine KSD mainspring retainer would even work with my ambiguously bootlegged KSD knockoff grips, so I wouldn't have you pay to ship me a spare one. I'd rather just modify the grips anyway, it'll give me a little side project for a rainy day. I should be getting a new Buck 110 in the mail in a couple of weeks, so maybe I'll even whittle away at it with that a little at a time until the grips fit with the Hogue retainer.
